I’m convinced Jay Leno is a hoarder. I mean, the man has some 300 cars in his “garage.” And even though his stuff is all shiny and historic and operational, and he has a website devoted to it — is it really that different from the plastic fast-food utensils and condiment packages that overflow your Great Aunt Sarah’s back bedroom?
I think not.
Now, clinically speaking, the difference between “hoarding” and “collecting” is that collectors are proud of their collections, keep them all spiffy, have tidy shrines devoted to them and will force people to come over and look at them.
Hoarders, on the other hand, feel guilty about their collections, do not maintain them, store them in disarray and try to prevent people from getting wind of them (sometimes literally getting wind of them).
I submit, Jay, that the only real difference between collectors and hoarders is money. If you have enough money, you keep your well-oiled stuff as a pretty collection. If you don’t have enough money, you pile up your broken stuff in a hoard and wait for the day that you do.
But at least you’ve got the stuff, right? You’re halfway there.
“Collector” cases to point:
-Jay Leno, car collector (rich)
-Imelda Marcos, shoe collector (rich)
-Princes of India, jewel collectors (rich)
“Hoarder” cases to point:
- Your Great Aunt Sarah, condiment hoarder (not so rich)
- Langley Collyer, famous hoarder (lived in squalor)
- My garage (’nuff said)
I think that is sufficient to prove my hypothesis. But the third item above, under collector cases, the jewel collections of Indian princes, brings up an interesting point. Jewel collections may also be called hoards, if they are found hidden away. Consider the “Viking hoard of jewels” that was dug up in Britain in 2007. So now, there, a hoard is a good thing.
It just goes to show that, when you are rich, everything you touch is considered cool — well, that is, unless you are Mel Gibson.
But what about those folks who do not have money, yet still manage to maintain their collections in a neatly organized fashion — and are proud to show them to you, no matter how odd they are?
Are they hoarders or collectors?
The following collections really exist:
- Graham Barker’s navel fluff collection (That’s belly-button lint.)
- Lydia’s collection of old AOL CDs (I think I have a collection like this.)
- Phil Miller’s collection of sugar packets (We should introduce him to Great Aunt Sarah.)
In fact, all over this country, there are quirky collections, museums and points of tourist interest that, without the publicity, would definitely fall under the shadow of hoarding.
Take for instance:
- Bottle houses. Until the bottles are neatly arranged in a wall where the sunlight can pass through them they are, well, trash – right?
- The Asphalt Museum in Sacramento. Here you can spend hours perusing chunks of asphalt from different highways.
Seriously? If located somewhere else, this material would be considered landfill.
- The Museum of Burnt Food (www.burntfoodmuseum.com). I expect the majority opinion would be that hoarding chunks of burnt food is no better than, and probably worse than, hoarding plastic forks — that is until you put the charred remains in a museum. Then, it’s art.
And if the char marks look like Jesus, so much the better.
But having pride in your hoard doesn’t necessarily mean you will display it. Those Vikings were very proud of their treasure, I’m sure. But the reason they hoarded it, hid it, was so it wouldn’t be taken from them.
That means that whether a hoard is considered a negative thing or a positive thing really arises from the owner’s attitude about it.
(Though being rich, Jay, sure helps with the PR, doesn’t it?)
So, there you go. Let your freak flag fly. Open a museum, and proudly stock it with your jars of belly-button lint and your ketchup packets, your dirt clods and petrified poop, your stacks of old newspapers and mummified cats. Let the world share in your joy.
Certainly, if you are rich, you will be viewed as cool for doing this — or at least thought of as eccentric, in a good way.
If you’re not rich, maybe you’ll be labeled as crazy.
But either way you’ll get the junk out of your house.
Jim Walker can be reached at [email protected] . His column reflects his own views, not necessarily those of The Signal.
