Witty but not cheesy.
Questioning but not judgmental.
Pensive but not confusing.
Two short lines have church members searching for just the right balance of tact and candor every few weeks. Believe it or not, a good amount of thought goes into deciding what phrase or Bible verse should be displayed on the church marquees that sit between the road and the worship buildings.
As motorists whiz down Bouquet Canyon Road or Newhall Avenue, the signs may be easy to pass without a glance.
But the challenge to catch the driving public’s attention with a one-liner makes the decision all the more entertaining for those who decide the signs’ content.
“You want to be very light, just make people think or put a smile on their face,” said Rod Belcher of First Presbyterian Church in Newhall.
Designated sign changer
Belcher has been in charge of First Presbyterian’s sign for about a year and a half. He took over the responsibility, he said, when the previous sign changer of five years burned out.
Belcher, a retired 67-year-old with an outgoing personality, stepped in, willing to take on a task he anticipated would be “fun.”
“I knew I could come up with a bunch of cute slogans or sayings to make people think,” he said.
And ever since Belcher was approved by the church’s board as the designated sign changer, he’s had plenty of fun and received continuous feedback.
“I go to the Senior Center for lunch, and everyone wants to know what’s going to be on the sign next,” he said. “I get a lot of compliments on what we put up there.”
One of Belcher’s personal favorites drew much feedback “You never see a U-Haul behind a hearse.”
Its meaning: Material belongings are not eternal, Belcher said.
“I got a lot of response from that one,” he said. “People had to think about it for a minute.”
Away from offense
A simple Google search for “church signs” will pull up dozens of websites on catchy phrases. But some are not so funny and that is where the filtering process comes in, said Pastor Billy Ford at Bouquet Canyon Church in Saugus.
What may pass for appropriate in the Bible Belt may not go over well in Southern California, Ford said.
Local church leaders aren’t interested in the trial-and-error approach. The signs have the potential to draw the attention of hundreds of motorists each day.
“A lot of thought goes into it because you never know how many people are going to be reading this,” Robinson said.
They’re not trying to push the lines. They simply want to encourage, entertain or inform.
“We don’t want to offend anyone if we can help it,” Ford said.
Belcher agreed.
“We don’t want to be politically incorrect or controversial,” Belcher said. “I eliminate that altogether.”
Sometimes the goal is to draw out a chuckle or thoughtful moment. Other times, the signs might simply be used as a means to advertise a church event.
Belcher said he’s only received one e-mail complaint. A man from the community took offense to a past sign phrase outside First Presbyterian. The phrase: “Hang out for Jesus, He hung out for you.”
The church sent the man an apology and immediately removed the phrase, Belcher said.
Finding their material
Ford said he has often used online resources, such as lists found through an Internet search, for sign material.
He likes to steer away from the cheesy phrases. For example, he wasn’t a fan of: “The best vitamin for a friend is B1.”
Sometimes inspiration comes from within.
“It just depends on what’s in my heart at the moment,” he said.
Ford also likes to coordinate the sign’s phrase or Bible verse with Sunday’s message. But pulling a Bible verse means searching for a short one.
Last week’s sign read: “I am the Good Shepherd. – Jesus.”
Every couple of week’s Ford lists about seven or eight potential sign candidates. He hands them off to office administrator Margaret Robinson, who gives feedback or suggestions for the list.
Belcher gets much of his material from a booklet of phrases he and his wife purchased. But he also receives e-mailed suggestions occasionally from friends across the country. They send Belcher pictures of signs they have passed by.
Every once in a while Belcher and Ford come up with their own material. Belcher enjoys taking opportunities to be creative. A pastor’s vacation week opened up an opportunity for Belcher to have some fun.
That week, the sign read: “Pastor’s on vacation, come Sunday to party with us.”
One-quote sermons
Agua Dulce resident Lisa Burgard used to pass by First Presbyterian’s sign three times a week on her way to a pilates class. Several times she’d find herself calling up her mother in West Virginia to tell her about the phrases.
“It’s like a one-quote sermon,” Burgard said. “It makes you stop and think.”
Burgard, who was searching for a church at time, would often find herself contemplating the phrase for the rest of her day. Eventually, her mother urged: if you like the signs so much, maybe you should check out the church.
Burgard and her family have been attending First Presbyterian for several years now. The signs did not deceive, she said. She experiences the same kind of spiritual uplifting and thought from the Sunday sermons as she did from the signs, she said.
‘A positive thing’
The phrases are not simply a marketing tool designed to get more bodies into the pews, but rather, they are seen as an outreach, leaders said.
“It’s been a positive thing for the community,” said Pastor Bill Barnes of First Presbyterian.
Burgard is living proof that the signs can make a difference. She’s not the only one in appreciation of the signs.
“We do get people from time to time where I find out what’s written on the sign really touches them,” Ford said.
Just last Sunday a first-time visitor to Bouquet Canyon Church confronted Ford. The woman told Ford that when she gets off work at midnight that she looks forward to reading the sign.
“She’d actually pull into the parking lot when she felt overwhelmed,” Ford said.
The woman’s recent favorite, Ford said, was: “Come in for a faith lift.”
