The city may have prevailed this week in an 11-year battle with the owner of the Santa Clarita Athletic Club, who broke the city’s sign ordinance with his large sign overlooking Interstate 5 and Calgrove Boulevard.
The city first contacted the owner in 1999, asking him to remove his sign.
The 40-foot-tall pylon-style sign, which faced the I-5 and featured an electronic message reader, was larger and taller than the city allows.
The club fought tooth and nail to keep its sign where it was, but missed two crucial steps.
According to 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals’ statement released Monday, the club owner did not file paperwork challenging a Santa Clarita Planning Commission decision allowing the sign to be removed, and he did not challenge an assessment that he owed the city $47,000 to cover the cost of removing the sign.
Because the club didn’t exhaust its options before going to court, the appeals court rejected the case, according to the statement.
In 1999, the city let the club know its sign was too big. The owner applied for a sign variance request, which the city denied.
The club appealed to the planning commission and met another denial. The club appealed to the City Council, which referred the issue to staff to work out a compromise. Such a compromise was never reached.
By March 2006, the back-and-forth had continued to a fever pitch, with the club appealing and the city denying the appeal.
The city finally removed the sign from the club’s property.
A year later, the club filed a lawsuit with the California Superior Court alleging the city violated its rights under the First, Fifth and Fourteenth amendments. The club lost. The club appealed, and lost again.
Now, the gym’s only recourse is to appeal to the California Supreme Court.
