ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Our View: For governor, vote for none of the above

The Signal's Editorial Board

Meg Whitman vs. Jerry Brown: One of them will be the next governor of California. But does either candidate instill confidence that he or she is the right leader to take the helm of this badly damaged state and its almost $20 billion deficit?

For the five members of The Signal’s Editorial Board, the answer is a resounding “No.”

Even in a race with two bad choices, the Editorial Board’s philosophy has always been to endorse, because after all, the

voter has to choose someone.

When deciding our opinion, it is not unusual for the five of us to have a vigorous debate. That was certainly the case with Whitman and Brown. (And yes, we know there are other candidates, but does anyone think any of them are a serious candidate who will get more than a single digit percentage of the votes?)

With any endorsed candidate, we want to list the positives they would bring to the job. For governor, all five of us struggled to do that, and in fact, found ourselves attempting to justify Whitman or Brown by stating what they would prevent the other from doing.

As one Editorial Board member put it: “A lot of people will be voting defensively in this election. Many voters will be faced with casting their ballot for the lesser of two distasteful choices.”

So with the Nov. 2 election just a few weeks away, what type of campaigning have we seen from these two candidates? The toxic variety that focuses far more on personal attacks, name-calling and political rhetoric in the place of meaningful and decisive policies regarding what the next governor must do.

In Whitman, we have a heartless Republican. She has already spent around $150 million (most of it her money, and more than 10 times what Brown has spent).

She showed terrible judgment or has been chronically dishonest in discussing how she handled her time at Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (the IPO-spinning scandal), what happened at the end of her tenure at eBay Inc. (she received a bonus of more than $100 million at the same time the company was announcing significant layoffs) and the handling and firing of her longtime “member of the family” housekeeper.

And for much of her life, Whitman has shown little interest in her civic responsibilities, never casting a vote in any election for 25 years before finally registering to vote in 2002.

In Brown, we have a spineless Democrat who throughout this campaign and past campaigns has said what he thinks will get him elected. His promise of no new taxes without the vote of the people may get him some votes, but it’s bad policy and will only prolong and make worse the ills of the state.

Brown also says once he lays out his plan, the Legislature will bear down, work harder and make the right decisions.

Really? As a former governor (he left office in 1972), he must struggle keeping a straight face when making this statement.

Brown is a lifelong politician, who after being California governor, ran for president (a couple of times), took time to seek spiritual fulfillment, became a party bigwig, was elected mayor of Oakland — a deeply troubled city both before he became mayor and after — and most recently, won yet another election to be the state’s attorney general.

One of the only good things about this election is that Whitman and Brown are very different people. The lifetime businesswoman and lifetime politician have proposed very different policies and plans to fix California.

On the most important issues to voters — a terrible economy, a lack of jobs/high unemployment and the state’s fiscal crisis — they have proposed very different, but equally fallible, solutions.

Whitman will go after bad regulations and reduce taxes, especially the capital gains tax. She feels the resulting tax savings will be invested back into the California economy, which will be good for California businesses, increase jobs and result in more state revenue.

The problem with this plan is that capital gains alone generates up to $11 billion in annual revenue, and with the mess the state is in, why would anyone want to invest in it? So her policy to address our ills could end up being an $11 billion giveaway!

Meanwhile, Brown’s job-creation policy is relying way too heavily on the “green economy” to create a bunch of jobs. That hasn’t happened anywhere. Even though more and more economists are saying, “The green economy is the future, and always will be,” one of Brown’s big fixes sounds like a nonstarter with no immediate benefit.

We don’t often agree with the L.A. Times’ editorial opinions, but in a recent editorial column on the governor’s race, we think they were right on:

“We need a leader deft and clever enough to move Californians away from a three-decade pattern of undermining our own government, checking and counterchecking ourselves with selfish initiatives to lock up special-program spending, lock out political decision-making and accountability and lock in a perpetual and destructive budget standoff, year after year.

“Fate presents the state instead with two candidates who fall well short of our current needs.” (Emphasis ours.)

We could not have said it better. So The Signal’s Editorial Board is unable in good faith to endorse either candidate. However, like all voters, when the five of us on the Board cast our ballots, we will have to make a choice.

Meg Whitman vs. Jerry Brown. Yes, one of them will be the next governor of California ... unfortunately.

← Back to 2010

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
35177
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 925 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 2 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_32_local
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0