ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Court: Boy can’t sue district

Crime: Appeals court rules that damages cannot be sought from Hart district for alleged molestation

A student who said he was sexually molested in 2007 by a former Golden Valley High School guidance counselor is not able to sue the William S. Hart Union High School District for negligence, a California appeals court ruled earlier this month.

The Second District Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the boy could not seek damages from the school district because the alleged molestation was outside of the scope of work the counselor, Roselyn Hubbell, was hired to perform.

The lawsuit claims that school district officials knew before hiring Hubbell that she had sexually molested children, but it did nothing to protect students from her.

The boy’s attorney, Vince Finaldi, said Friday that the appeals court ruling contradicts the California Constitution, which mandates public schools provide a safe environment for students — something Golden Valley High School officials failed to do, he said.

Finaldi said he plans to file a petition in December to request that the California Supreme Court rule on the case.

Meanwhile, attorneys representing the school district said the appeals court ruling was founded and that the school had no way of knowing Hubbell was capable of molesting children.

The court’s decision is the latest chapter in a three-year saga for Hubbell, who was forced to register as a sex offender after she was arrested in 2008 trying to check into a motel with a different underage boy.

Background

Hubbell resigned from Golden Valley High School in May 2008 after she was accused having a sexual relationship with two students.

The lawsuit alleges that Hubbell, then 32, had a sexual relationship with the 14-year-old for nearly nine months in 2007, on and off the Golden Valley High campus.

The Los Angeles County District Attorney did not press criminal charges against Hubbell because the boy would not admit to a sexual relationship at the time, according to past reports.

“(My son) didn’t want to tell the truth,” said the boy’s adopted mother on Friday. “(Hubbell) made him promise her to never open his mouth.”

The Signal is withholding the name of the now-18-year-old, as well as the name of his mother, to protect his identity.

Four months after the boy’s mother filed the lawsuit against the school district in January 2008, Hubbell was arrested with a different boy while trying to check into a San Fernando Valley motel.

She pleaded no contest in February 2009 to one misdemeanor count of sexual molestation in connection with that case.

Hubbell, 35, is currently living in Los Angeles County, according to the state’s sex offender’s registry.

‘I heard noises’

The fallout in the months and years after the alleged sexual affair with Hubbell was difficult for her son to handle, the student’s mother said.

It took a year’s worth of counseling for him to begin to realize that he had been abused.

“He felt like it was his fault,” his mother said. “My son was victimized by this woman when he was only 14 years old. It’s really affected him a lot.”

He is currently attending high school in the Santa Clarita Valley and hopes to graduate in December, she said.

In 2007, Hubbell visited her son often at their Canyon Country home, she said. Sometimes Hubbell brought her son food before going to his bedroom.

“I got suspicious because she always came and went into his room for hours,” she recalled. “I thought she was talking to him about his behavior.”

She felt so comfortable with Hubbell that she gave Hubbell a set of keys to her home.

But that trust was betrayed when she overheard what she now believes was Hubbell and her son having sex.

One day when she returned from the store, she saw Hubbell’s van parked in front of her house. She quietly entered her home to find out what was going on.

“I came in very quiet and I heard something was going on. I heard noises,” she said. “You know when somebody is making love. They heard me, I think.”

Later, she found love notes Hubbell had written to her adopted son.

Soon after, she told her son’s social worker that Hubbell was having a sexual affair with a minor.

“It became obvious what was going on,” she said. “They went to Venice Beach, Camarillo,” she said. “A lot of places.”

She said she thinks the school is responsible for what happened to her son and hopes the California Supreme Court will overturn the lower court’s ruling.

“I feel betrayed by (Hubbell) because I opened my home to her,” she said. “I wish (Hubbell to be in jail, but that wish didn’t come through for me.”

The ruling

The Second District Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the William S. Hart Union High School District cannot be held responsible for the alleged sexual molestation because it was far outside the scope of counseling work Hubbell was hired to perform.

Furthermore, there is no California statute that holds school districts responsible for negligent hiring or training.

But in a 27-page dissent, Presiding Justice Robert M. Mallano said Hart district officials’ failure to supervise Hubbell lead to the 14-year-old being molested.

“According to the complaint, the school district knew before and after hiring the guidance counselor that she had molested, and was continuing to molest, students,” Mallano wrote. “After hiring her, the district knew she was unfit for the job, but took no action to supervise, train, or discharge her. As a consequence, (the student) was sexually molested.”

Attorneys representing the school district said Hubbell had no history of molesting children.

“Before this happened, there was nothing in (Hubbell’s) history or background that would indicate this,” said Stephen Harber, an attorney representing the district. “The counselor is the wrongdoer, but not the school district, and to require the taxpayers (to pay) for this kind of conduct is not right.”

Finaldi, said he was flabbergasted by the court’s ruling and said the decision puts millions of children across the state at risk of sexual abuse.

“If the state of California is going to require kids to go to school, they need to make sure those schools are safe.” Finaldi said. “(The ruling) makes public schools and public entities more dangerous.”

← Back to 2010

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
36611
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,034 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 5 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_36_local
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/15 mentions: Santa Clarita, Canyon Country, Hart district, William S. Hart, Golden Valley High, Hart Union]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Jonathan Randles]
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 8, national 1