A Chatsworth Superior Court judge denied a local resident’s request for Santa Clarita officials to release more documents about the city’s decision to take over the three local libraries from the county library system, officials said Friday.
City Attorney Carl Newton said Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Barbara Scheper deemed that there was no urgency to release the documents.
Three lawsuits resulted from the Santa Clarita City Council’s decision in August to withdraw from the Los Angeles County Library system. The city is in the process of creating a city-library system that will be operated by the library-management firm Library Systems & Services LLC., or LSSI.
The first two lawsuits were filed by Save Our Library Inc., a nonprofit corporation. The lawsuits are separate but intimately related, and allege violations of library patrons’ privacy rights.
The lawsuits allege that the city will violate library patron’s privacy rights when it hands over data on borrowing habits and other information to LSSI.
City officials have maintained that LSSI is bound by state law to not share information or use it for soliciting.
A third lawsuit, filed by Edward Shain, alleges a violation of the state’s open-meeting law.
The Brown Act requires government bodies to conduct business in public. If a majority of the five-member City Council had discussions and came to an agreement to approve the library takeover before the vote, this would be a violation of the Brown Act.
The lawsuit alleges the City Council must have reached a consensus before it voted Aug. 24. Council members raised suspicions when they voted to withdraw from the county system and enter into a $19.1-million, five-year contract with LSSI during that meeting after a single public hearing.
The City Council voted after three hours of public testimony, during which the vast majority of 150 attendees opposed the takeover.
The city requested a protective order to prevent city officials and staff, including Deputy City Manager Darren Hernandez and former City Councilman TimBen Boydston, from testifying to help build the cases.
The city is also asking that the three cases be consolidated. Attorney Don Ricketts, who represents both the Save Our Library group and Shain, said Friday he would move to consolidate, in agreement with the city.
Decisions on those two requests were continued until Dec. 21, Newton said.
