Your editorial (“An invitation to city’s library critics,” Nov. 14) sets forth a fuller recitation of the facts leading up to the (Santa Clarita City) Council’s Aug. 24 vote to create the Santa Clarita Public Library and have it operated by Library System & Services LLC, or LSSI, than has been forthcoming from the city to date — voluntarily or in response to Public Records Act requests by several individuals.
They further establish that both of the council’s decisions were made well prior to the Aug. 24 vote.
The factual record is still, however, incomplete.
While “secret meetings” are what the public commonly understands is a violation of the Brown Act, its central provision is to prohibit making decisions in advance of a vote — whether done secretly or otherwise.
Making them secretly for the purpose of minimizing opposition is a second offense that violates the constitutional right to participate in governmental decisions with free access to information that makes participation meaningful.
The library decision appears to be an example of a continuing course of conduct to suppress opposition to this administration’s views.
As the editorial correctly points out, the lawsuits do allege that a naked promise by LSSI to “obey all laws” is insufficient.
The Signal’s position that that is enough is unsupported by respected academics, the editorial policy of responsible journals, the American Library Association (and its code of ethics) and privacy organizations.
It is difficult to understand why the city would not, at least, demand more stringent privacy provisions and, more appropriate, control the private information itself as the county does.
While initial opposition to withdrawal (when almost nothing was known of the city’s plans) was organized by SEIU, that is no longer the case. The union withdrew from the fray, finding that it could not afford to expend further time and money to save “only” 80 jobs.
Both the city and the union threw the library employees under the bus.
There does not appear to be any organized opposition at this time to the LSSI takeover. Applications by only 24 individuals to the city’s advisory committee suggest that the library issues — despite all of the heat and light — are not of deep concern to many people.
But that is still an open question. Clearly, beyond the legal issues raised by the lawsuits, the administration’s lack of transparency, as a matter of policy, should be of great concern.
If there is no evidence of the kind of economic greed that drove the administration in the city of Bell at this point, the Bell culture that views public proceedings as rubber stamps for decisions made in advance does seem prevalent here.
This appears to be a short-term, stop-gap measure to sustain the Old Town Newhall project, anchored by a new library building with facilities far in excess of those necessary to support the Newhall area.
Property taxes from the Newhall area alone cannot support this expansive new library, and damn the torpedoes, full-speed ahead, the administration is going to build that library, whether needed or not, and at the expense of the other two libraries — and all of us.
None can deny, however, that economics aside, the new library would be a welcome addition and would further the goal of turning downtown Newhall into a little Carmel.
Perhaps the goal could be achieved by consolidating Valencia and Newhall (libraries). The city does not own the Valencia property and would have to lease it from the county to keep it open.
At this point, the council should formally withhold explicit approval of the LSSI contract until everyone understands what is going to be done and how.
An LSSI takeover is not being opposed only in Santa Clarita, but in other cities where the opposition has been effectively organized, and cities have been slow, deliberate and open in their consideration of the question.
A number of municipalities, after a trial period with LSSI, have canceled their contracts. The basic questions in August and now are: Why the rush? Why in secret?
Finally, my clients, Save Our Library Inc. and Ed Shain are not now nor ever have been affiliated with the union or supported by it. Nor have I.
The lawsuits were not discussed with it in advance nor is it providing any resources to support them. Save Our Library Inc. is a private, nonprofit corporation that is privately funded.
Our only interest and concern is with creating a Santa Clarita Public Library that continues to provide, at least, the level and quality of service that has been provided by the county — and does so with integrity.
Thank you for considering our views.
Don Ricketts is a Santa Clarita lawyer. He may be reached by e-mail at [email protected] . His column reflects his own views and not necessarily those of The Signal.
