Big news! Carole Lutness got crushed (again) running in a local race against an incumbent, this time for Castaic Lake Water Agency board.
Less big news! Carole will show up at a City Council meeting near you stating once again the ancient trope that “clean money” would propel her righteous cause to victory, thwarting the evil corporate interests against which she battles.
Now move to City Council elections. The still-growing tribe of unsuccessful challengers to impervious incumbents consider similar tropes to justify their complete waste of time, and in some cases money, in the endeavor.
Now, David Gauny came painfully close to unseating incumbent Frank Ferry in the April 2010 City Council election, but I now do believe that one can factually demonstrate that Ferry devoted so little effort to his re-election that he might not have risen from the couch to answer the door to speak to one of his own campaign volunteers.
The oft-used rallying cry “Know your incumbents! No votes for incumbents!” starts to ring like a hollow joke a mere six months on.
So how do the unsuccessful candidates sleep at night? They grumble about the incumbents’ advantage in fundraising, which the incumbents solidified soon after the election by raising the contribution limits so they could spend one-third of the time raising the $100K necessary to provide comfort that they could bury any opposition with glossy mailers containing Hollywood models.
They also grumble about the seeming conspiracy of holding the election in April rather than November to depress turnout to also favor the incumbents. Surely a higher turnout would propel the righteous challengers to victory?
Well, it turns out that if the incumbents really wished to cement their dynastic rule, they would boldly move the election to November and include it in the general-election ballot.
A primer on voters and the well-documented concept of “rational ignorance”: It costs much in time and effort to keep oneself apprised of any political issue. (I endured the cost of a deletion of a recorded episode of “Terriers” due to election night activity.)
Therefore, the rational voter acting on a purely economic basis will not bother to learn anything, since his or her ignorant vote carries exactly the same weight as the well-informed vote.
Thus the theory goes, increasing turnout just brings more rationally ignorant voters into the electorate to somehow determine their votes based on some random decision.
Through various methods, one can establish that 4 percent of the 17 percent of voters who cast ballots in the 2010 Santa Clarita City Council election constitute the rationally ignorant who do not bother to read local newspapers or other news sources.
These 4 percent overwhelmingly (75-percent-to-25-percent) vote for the incumbents, propelling them to victory after victory. In the last election, incumbents soaked up 53 percent of the votes to the challengers’ 47 percent.
They base their decision on what one elected official calls “the city is not burning” theory. (“I came out to the driveway this morning and did not find the city burning so the incumbents must be doing a great job.”)
But what about moving the election to November?
Consider the case of Camarillo, a city in Ventura County of similar demographic makeup, though about one-third the size of Santa Clarita, with a five-person at-large City Council that holds elections in November.
Results from Camarillo’s most recent election shows an astounding turnout of 44 percent of eligible voters, more than 250-percent higher than Santa Clarita’s anemic 17 percent just six months ago.
But one can demonstrate from the results that this heightened turnout only helped the three incumbents up for re-election, who between them shared 64 years of service.
The Camarillo incumbents made their Santa Clarita counterparts look absolutely weak, soaking up 60 percent of the vote to the challengers’ 40 percent, which translated into the closest challenger falling a stunning 3,800 votes behind the third-place incumbent.
Another modeling of the Camarillo results implies the extra turnout went 65 percent for the incumbents and 35 percent to the challengers.
The numbers don’t lie. The rationally ignorant with their standing decision to vote for incumbents constitute the bane of any challenger, and would also further doom the earnest hopes of any challenger in a future Santa Clarita race.
It may seem counterintuitive, but the challengers in any Santa Clarita City Council election should take great steps to actually depress turnout in the hopes of depressing that pool of rationally ignorant voters on which the incumbents will feast.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident. His column reflects his own views and not necessarily those of The Signal. “Myers’ Musings” appears Sundays in The Signal.
