Local seniors rallied Thursday to defend the Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center against claims by two patrons of physical and verbal abuse from volunteer and administrative staff there.
“In my opinion, (the complainants) are looking for trouble,” said longtime Senior Center patron Mark Jewett. “This is a good place for seniors to come and have a good meal with their friends.”
Senior Center regular Richard Hitchcock, 83, also refuted the allegations of abuse.
As the sounds of friendly chatter filled the lunchroom, jammed with about 200 seniors at closely spaced cafeteria-style tables, Hitchcock said the volunteer’s alleged assault was nothing more than a tap on the shoulder. “She calls that hitting,” he said of the complainant.
Martie Rodriguez, who has eaten lunch at the local center for more than two years, said that when she shared a table with the two protesters, she witnessed nothing more than a volunteer brushing up against one of them as she moved about helping patrons in the crowded lunchroom.
Santa Clarita residents Luis Lovato, 62, and Carmelita McClaine, 70, accused a Senior Center volunteer and staff members of physically and verbally assaulting them multiple times over the past year.
They lodged their complaints Tuesday during a Santa Clarita Valley Committee on Aging hearing. Lovato also filed a Sheriff’s Department complaint against center Director James Morgan on Tuesday, alleging the administrator assaulted him.
The report describes an incident earlier this week in which Lovato said Morgan put his arm around him and asked him to leave the Senior Center. The longtime Santa Clarita resident refused to leave and was served lunch.
On Thursday morning, McClaine paced in front of the Senior Center while Lovato, wearing a motorcycle helmet, held a sign asking for help.
“Our volunteers are amazing — they’re here for all the right reasons,” said Robin Clough, recreation and volunteer director at the Senior Center.
Clough said she was surprised to hear of Lovato and McClaine’s complaints against an elderly volunteer and against Santa Clarita Senior Center Director James Morgan, since she said she hadn’t witnessed or heard of any harassment taking place in the center during her six years there.
For many of the residents who rely on the Senior Center’s weekday meals, supportive services and social events, the local organization is a lifeline, said Kathy Crone, executive director of the Senior Center Foundation.
When asked what she thought about Lovato’s protest Thursday, Crone said, “I don’t want anybody to miss a meal, but I also don’t want him to challenge the integrity of this wonderful place that’s done so much good.”
Both she and Morgan stressed that the nonprofit center couldn’t run without its approximately 300-strong volunteer staff, many of whom are in their 80s and 90s.
Los Angeles County sheriff’s detectives were investigating Lovato’s complaint.

