ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Full Speed to Port!

Gary Horton: Mulling over mandates in medical care

Last week’s column discussing our aggravating health-insurance situation took notable traction.

Last Saturday, The Signal published related Internet comments — and it was surprising to see that when it comes to medical coverage, a majority of the public comes together in general opinion.

The common bonds of age and fear of affliction join adults together more strongly than political gravities pull us apart.

We seem to agree that the situation as it exists now is untenable; that most feel at serious personal financial risk should they turn ill, and most are solidly pinched by the cost of their own insurance, and we both resent and pity those choosing to, or forced to, freeload on the system.

We have common concerns, yet remain at odds on how just to fix it. Many don’t understand “Obamacare” — and chaffing at the concept of mandated insurance contained in the plan. “Mandates” are the plan’s greatest flashpoint.

A local doctor wrote me with his own ideas, forged from his medical pragmatism. He’s all in for mandates, and even more:

“I think Obamacare is an OK idea that just needs some tweaking. Those who want to repeal it are incensed by the mandates to purchase health care. But it is imperative to have such mandates, otherwise nothing will change.

“For example, I know a hair stylist who makes $80,000 a year, bought a 2,300 (square foot) home for $350,000, has two cars, an ATV and a Jet Ski. But she chooses to not ‘waste’ money on health insurance.

“Later, when she crashes the Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital emergency room, someone will pay, but it won’t be her — it will be ‘us.’ So who picks up the tab on her insurance?

“And I’m all for a sin tax on tobacco and all booze, high-fructose corn syrup and maybe even mom’s apple pie if it is too calorie-dense. Tax the heck out of lard and all fatty foods. But then, that would harm the scooter industry, which Medicare and Medi-Cal have been helping make one of America’s greatest industries, with scooter makers catering to the fast-growing obesity market...

“Taxing fat and vice seems like a fair way to pay for at least some of the 40 million uninsured, while nudging them and all of us stop abusing our bodies in ways that keep raising the bills in the first place.”

One doctor’s pragmatism: mandated insurance, and government intervention nudging us toward healthy lifestyles.

Some cry “socialism” or “government intrusion.” Yet similar mandates already exist, keeping society safe and functioning in other areas of life.

Government mandates we educate our kids: You must school your kids either in public, private or home settings.

We’re mandated to pay for education with taxes, tuition or home-school costs. And most agree this is reasonable: For society to succeed, the populace must be educated.

We mandate Social Security, and most agree that, too, is smart. Who wants grandmas and grandpas out on the streets panhandling because they never saved for old age? Yes, they should save, but many don’t or can’t.

And we also mandate certain vaccinations, as society doesn’t want anyone spreading deadly, infectious diseases.

Mandates happen all around us, and most make common sense. And now, we’ve chosen to mandate insurance, because not having insurance hurts both individuals and society at large.

Those who don’t have insurance burden those who do. Uninsured patients’ hospital bills become the public’s bills, and together we suck it up in higher insurance premiums. It may not read like a bank robbery in the papers, but it still feels like theft.

And as the doctor says, unhealthy lifestyles of excessive consumption dramatically raise everyone’s medical costs through rocketing diabetes, heart disease and cancer rates. Here, too, society pays communally for individuals’ personal life choices. How can this be fair?

While not nearly dramatic as spreading infectious diseases, those indulging in unhealthy lifestyles impose costs onto others.

If education, vaccinations and age security are public concerns, surely medical insurance and healthy living stand on equal footing.

Socialist thinking, or common sense? Government intrusion, or smart public policy? Intrusive mandates, or requiring adults to live responsibly for the public good?

For fairness’ sake, the real issue seems not mandates themselves, but how to make mandated insurance affordable for all.

And while we’re at it, as long as we share costs in pooled insurance programs, pushing folks to live healthier makes sense, and makes medical care cheaper for all of us.

In an America where we pine to “go it alone,” health care realities pull us back together. We can scream and squirm, but in the end, what others do significantly impacts what we pay. Mandates and active social policy mitigate health care costs for our common good.

Intrusion or not, it’s only fair.

Gary Horton is a Santa Clarita resident. His column reflects his own views and not necessarily those of The Signal. “Full Speed to Port!” appears Wednesday in The Signal.

← Back to 2011

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
40591
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 827 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:local_contributor_marker [appears Wednesday in The Signal; is a Santa Clarita resident]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/3 mentions: Santa Clarita, Newhall, Henry Mayo]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Gary Horton]
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 6, national 1