With eight of its Foothill League wins coming by one goal, the league champion Saugus girls soccer team had played with fire all season.
In the first round of the CIF-Southern Section Division I playoffs, it finally caught up with the Centurions.
Saugus struggled to connect on its passes early on, fell behind by two goals in the second half and couldn’t come back in a 2-1 loss to Sunset League No. 3 seed Newport Harbor on Thursday at Saugus High School.
“Sometimes in soccer, you’ve got that element of luck to help you,” said Centurions head coach Natalie Helgeson, whose team went 10-0-0 in league play. “It didn’t feel like we had that today.”
In the 51st minute, shortly after the Sailors (8-12-3) opened up a 2-0 lead, Saugus (19-3-4) began to get on track offensively when forward Nicole Penick served up a corner kick to teammate Serena Smith-Banas, who headed it past goalkeeper Emily Browne.
“I think the goal pumped us up again,” Smith-Banas said. “We just needed something to give everyone hope.”
It gave the Centurions more than hope.
The play ushered in a slew of opportunities consisting of more corner kicks and deep throw-ins from Jill Allen. But nothing got through.
“They manage the game and play good soccer,” said Newport Harbor head coach Larry Draluck of Saugus. “We dodged a lot of bullets.”
The Centurions peppered Browne and looked like they would equalize on several opportunities, most notably when senior Colleen Ortega loaded up and drove a ball low in the 18-yard box off a Penick corner.
But before the shot crossed the goal line, Sailors midfielder Natalie Swift got a foot on the ball and cleared it from danger.
“They are a really good team and we came out flat,” Ortega said. “I hadn’t thought about it being my last game. It’s kind of hard to imagine. It’s a whirlwind.”
So was Newport Harbor’s first goal.
In the 24th minute, Swift sent in a shot from the top of the box that floated to the top left corner.
Though up 1-0, Draluck said he thought it was Saugus that was more invigorated by the goal.
“We just play good team defense,” Draluck said. “This is a very tough group. They were all fighting for one another.”
The Centurions responded with several shots that bounced off the post. But their inability to put together runs consistently left them down at halftime.
In the 46th minute, the Sailors got their second goal off a counterattack when Mary Yeager crossed the ball to Josie Jogwe, who played it low and past goalkeeper Madison Hebert.
Hebert played the second half in place of starter Kat Wieselthier.
They went largely unchallenged as Saugus put 16 shots on goal to three by Newport Harbor.
Browne had 10 saves in the game.
“Did we lose playing our best? No,” Helgeson said. “We did not play our best soccer.”


