The attorney for a group aimed at stopping Santa Clarita’s library takeover has requested Los Angeles Superior Court dismiss one of his lawsuits against the city, according to court documents obtained Wednesday.
Attorney Don Ricketts requested the court clerk dismiss without prejudice the entire complaint, which alleged a violation of California’s open-meeting law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, according to a copy of the Feb. 19 application obtained by The Signal.
Ricketts said Tuesday that he voluntarily dismissed the lawsuit. He declined to comment further.
The City Council voted in August to withdraw from the Los Angeles County Public Library system. The decision was met with much public outcry from library workers, volunteers and patrons, who questioned the City Council’s openness in discussing and deciding on the move.
The public first heard that the city would consider removing the Valencia, Newhall and Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy libraries from the county in favor of forming a city library system during a July 13 council meeting.
The City Council voted to withdraw on Aug. 24. That same night, the council voted to contract with the private library-management firm Library Systems and Services LLC to operate the three libraries.
The decision was seen as hasty by many people, and a group called Save Our Library Inc. formed to oppose the move.
Three lawsuits resulted.
In December, the Superior Court of California rejected the first complaint on the first lawsuit. That complaint alleged a privacy-rights violation.
A second complaint in that same lawsuit alleges that the city did not provide all the documents requested under the California Public Records Act.
“We disagree,” City Attorney Joe Montes said in an e-mail Wednesday.
The Public Records Act portion of the first lawsuit is pending.
The second lawsuit was the allegation of Brown Act violations.
A third lawsuit alleges the Santa Clarita City Council violated state law when it voted Jan. 25 to add the Santa Clarita Public Library to the city’s code.
The state’s education code mandates that a city form a library board of trustees before forming a public library system — which the city didn’t do, according to the lawsuit. Since the city didn’t do that, any action to form a library system is null, the lawsuit alleges.
The Superior Court of California will consider the city’s request to throw out that lawsuit March 21.
The city is due to begin operating the three libraries starting July 1.
A call Wednesday afternoon to Edward Shain, the plaintiff in Brown Act lawsuit, was not immediately returned.
Signal staff writer Laura Dixon contributed to this report.
