The city of Santa Clarita is off to a good start.
The City Council voted last week to tie up $2.85 million of its redevelopment housing money in a low- to moderate-income housing project to be built in the former Caltrans yard on Newhall Avenue.
That news might not be terribly provocative in normal times, but these are not normal times.
It’s precisely the sort of defensive maneuver cities up and down California are enacting to thwart Gov. Jerry Brown’s giant tax grab.
Oh sure, the voters said no more tax grabs. By a decisive, 61-to-39-percent margin four short months ago, they told the Sacramento politicians to keep their mitts off local tax dollars, including redevelopment funds.
Brown can’t take their money, so he’s attempting an end run. Eliminate the state’s 400 redevelopment agencies, and the tax dollars are no longer “local” — because the local agencies that collected them no longer exist.
There’s no guarantee the Legislature will approve Brown’s scheme at the end of the day — or that it would hold up in court. But in politics, as in life and in court, there are no guarantees.
So the City Council is doing what it must do to protect its redevelopment money.
That is its job.
It matters little whether you think Brown’s budget-balancing plan is the greatest thing since sliced bread. That’s not the point.
The city has a job. The City Council’s responsibility starts and stops at city limits. Just as it is the president’s job to uphold all federal laws, and the governor’s job to defend voter-approved ballot measures — a lesson each could stand to learn — it is the city’s job to safeguard its money — your money. It is money that belongs to the citizens of Santa Clarita and no one else.
You really wouldn’t want it any other way.
Fortunately, the city safeguards your money well. So well, in fact, that Santa Clarita has avoided the financial turmoil that has crippled other cities because Santa Clarita’s number-crunchers know how to mind the municipal pocketbook.
In the case of redevelopment, the trick is for a city to tie up its redevelopment tax increment dollars — the small slice of property tax that goes to eliminating blight in places like Old Town Newhall. (If you think Newhall is looking pretty nice now, you can thank redevelopment.)
If a city “encumbers” its redevelopment funds — meaning the money is dedicated to repaying debt the redevelopment agency has already incurred — the state can’t confiscate the money even if the agency itself no longer exists. The debt doesn’t go away. It must be paid back.
So cities and counties throughout California are hurriedly incurring debt — encumbering their redevelopment dollars — to pay for future rehab projects.
They aren’t stupid. They either move up their redevelopment time lines or risk losing everything.
Some random examples:
Foster City is encumbering $30 million of its redevelopment housing money, just as Santa Clarita did. (By law, 20 percent of any redevelopment agency’s funds must go to low- and moderate-income housing. Santa Clarita’s housing fund is lower by comparison because Santa Clarita’s redevelopment project area is actually quite small.)
Rancho Mirage is encumbering $32 million to pay for freeway and flood-control projects.
San Mateo is encumbering $40 million to finance a whole slew of projects from shoreline park improvements to parking and sewers.
Ontario is taking a bold move by transferring $335 million from the redevelopment agency to the city over five years. If redevelopment agencies go away, the city of Ontario would use the money for projects that otherwise would have been done by the redevelopment agency.
According to Ontario’s city staff report, this shift “will contractually commit available resources and projected net tax increment” — i.e., encumber the redevelopment money and protect it from the governor’s clutches.
We’ll see. As noted, in politics there are no guarantees, and on Feb. 23, the governor made his counter-move.
On that date — more than three weeks after his budget bill was due — he finally released his proposed “redevelopment agency dissolution” language.
In it, he carved out a way for the state to stop redevelopment decisions (including debt decisions) retroactively if they were made after Jan. 1, 2011.
Of course, the Legislature would have to agree. But that is Brown’s latest play.
He’s not stupid, either. He sees the cities chipping away at the $1.7 billion he hopes to grab from redevelopment.
Meantime, Santa Clarita has some more financial maneuvering to do.
Some of Santa Clarita’s redevelopment money is already safe. In addition to the $2.85 million for housing, approximately $12 million in redevelopment money is tied up in the $25 million Newhall Library — about half its cost.
It was never the intent for redevelopment to finance the library outright. Libraries are supposed to be built with developer fees and library taxes.
Rather, redevelopment fronted the money for all the familiar reasons — the county refused to spend developer fees or library tax money on the construction, and the city hasn’t yet collected library taxes.
Basically it was a loan from the redevelopment agency — which underscores the importance of redevelopment agencies.
Redevelopment can finance community projects while you’re waiting for the “appropriate” funding to come through.
If redevelopment money is permanently tied up in the library, it would be a shame, but so be it. This is war.
If our municipal money managers are as prudent as we think they are, they’ll waste no time in tying up the rest of their — our — redevelopment money.
If Ontario can shift its entire unencumbered redevelopment budget to the city, so can we.
It might be folly. The Legislature might not enact Brown’s move. But you never know.
All we can say with certainty is that the city’s got to try. Move it or risk losing it.
