In a letter The Signal obtained Thursday, a Sacramento-based taxpayer watchdog group said the city can’t collect the county’s special library tax without a vote of the people.
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association agreed with Los Angeles County’s legal position in the Feb. 17 letter.
“The city of Santa Clarita cannot assert collection authority for a tax it did not enact, and which was described to voters as being levied and collected by the county,” wrote Timothy Bittle, the association’s director of legal affairs. “And even if it could, the city cannot expend the revenue from that tax on a different library program.”
The Santa Clarita City Council voted in August to withdraw from the county library system and take over operations for the Valencia, Newhall and Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy libraries beginning July 1.
That’s when the city will begin collecting about $4.9 million in property-tax revenues. A private library-management firm, Library Systems & Services LLC, will receive about $3 million of that to operate the libraries.
At issue is the $1.4 million the county collects from Santa Clarita property owners via a $27 parcel tax.
In Santa Clarita, voters approved the special library tax. The money is spent on Santa Clarita’s libraries alone, supplementing the property-tax revenues.
In January, City Attorney Joe Montes said the city could levy the special library tax.
But the county, which will stop collecting the tax on July 1, disagrees.
“In our opinion, the city does not have the authority to collect the Measure L tax, unless it holds a special election and gets two-thirds approval from the electorate,” Deputy County Counsel Jill Jones said Thursday.
As Santa Clarita prepares to take over the local library system, city staff continue to explore their options, city spokeswoman Gail Ortiz said.
Ortiz stressed that the City Council has not decided which option it will take on the special tax matter.
Montes said that those options include levying the tax, holding a special election proposing a lower special tax, or refraining from collecting such a tax at all.
But the taxpayers association contends that levying the tax is not a legal possibility.
The letter quotes state law and previous litigation in making the case that levying the tax would be illegal.
“We hope the City Council agrees that money spent on an election to safeguard the city against litigation and possible refunds, attorney fees and penalties under Section 53728, is money well spent,” the letter concludes.
Montes said he and other city staff members are aware of the letter.
“We’re exploring our options,” he said.
The City Council is scheduled to discuss the special library tax during its May 10 meeting.
