ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Library petition is flawed

Community: City refutes claim of 10,000 signatures, noting several discrepancies

A stack of 10,000 signatures.

That’s what Lynne Plambeck, a last-minute spokeswoman for community groups opposing the city’s creation of its own library system, said she was turning over to the city during Tuesday night’s Santa Clarita City Council meeting: the signatures of 10,000 opponents of a city-library system, compiled via websites, community groups and individuals standing in front of the libraries.

City officials scoffed at the document’s gaps and inaccuracies, including what they said were clearly fake entries from the likes of Fred Flintstone, Axl Rose and Joel Wellcome.

Of the three, Wellcome is actually a confirmed Santa Clarita Valley resident.

But Wellcome coudn’t have signed the petition this week as noted, since he died more than a year ago, his wife, Pamela, said Thursday.

His signature was one of many discrepancies The Signal found within the Excel document that the city received.

But signature-gatherers maintain that many of the signatures are legitimate and represent a broad range of local residents against the planned municipal library system. And political experts say that petitions — even online ones — are an important part of democracy, warts and all.

The city’s plan involves withdrawing from the Los Angeles County Public Library system and contracting with a private library-management firm that will operate the Newhall, Valencia and Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy libraries for the city starting July 1.

Document full of holes

When the City Council voted in August to launch its own library system, community members stood outside SCV libraries to collect signatures on a petition warning that a city-run library system would bring patrons “greater cost, fewer books and less access.”

More recently, a variation of the petition has circulated on websites such as privatizationbeast.org, which reports 7,500 signatures have been gathered, and on scvfbg.org: Santa Clarita Voters for Better Government.

In addition to questionable names, several signatures were replaced by the word “Null” or were followed by the same name reprinted.

One name on the list was Berta Gonzalez-Harper. She’s a vocal supporter of the city’s decision to form its own library system.

“Nobody contacted me for a signature, nor would I have given it,” Gonzalez-Harper said.

Plambeck, who declined to release the name of the person who compiled the petition’s print and e-signatures, attributed the discrepancies to human error and people opting not to print their full names for privacy reasons.

Proponents of the library system could have added some fake signatures, too, Plambeck said.

“When you do a web petition, you can hope people are honest and care about the subject that’s going on, but we have a valley that is full of dirty tricks,” she said. “We felt it was legitimate. The purpose of this was to show the city there is broad concern over this issue.”

Petition’s claims

In recent months, the petition’s rhetoric has changed slightly, but the overall message opposing a city-run library system remains the same, Plambeck said.

The petition circulated this month cites unexpected costs and an insufficient assessment of patrons’ access “to a large collection of materials and services” under the county system.

Deputy City Manager Darren Hernandez responded to these claims Tuesday.

“The need to improve the local (library) collection is something we recognized last summer … when (the council) approved the 22 percent increase in the budget for library materials,” he said.

Aside from construction costs passed on from the county to finish the Canyon Country library’s expansion, Hernandez said the new library system hasn’t incurred any substantial unforeseen expenses.

The city’s contracted library management firm Library Systems & Services LLC, or LSSI, conducted a thorough study of local libraries’ current materials, Hernandez said. Residents’ reliance on the county’s inter-library loan network highlights the collection’s shortcomings, he said.

“The existing collection is relatively small. … The weakness of that collection is why people are concerned about not having adequate access to collections beyond the valley,” Hernandez said.

Additionally, he said library patrons would have access to a larger collection via the Inland Library Network’s interlibrary-loan system and through the purchase of $900,000 worth of new materials, Hernandez said.

That purchase was approved by the City Council on Tuesday night, along with other startup-related costs.

Petition vs. survey

Upon hearing the city’s criticism of the signatures, some petitioners called into question the city’s recent online survey, which was designed to assess local library patrons’ needs.

“Our petition has real names and real addresses. Theirs only has a ZIP code. … I could live in Maryland and just put in a local ZIP code,” said Lori Rivas, who co-wrote the petition.

Santa Clarita’s online survey garnered 2,986 responses, city spokeswoman Gail Ortiz said. Respondents answered questions about their age, languages spoken and how often they use their local libraries, among others.

Ortiz said the city couldn’t confirm respondents are SCV residents.

“We believe the majority of people were local because the only place we advertised was locally,” Ortiz said.

Tom Hogen-Esch, an associate political science professor at California State University, Northridge, said regardless of the form, community petitions are an important bellwether of public opinion.

“With the Internet, you have all kinds of potential for better democracy and worse democracy —– an online petition is hard to verify, but so is any other petition,” Hogan-Esch said.

Some petitioners said they felt disheartened that, after a stream of dozens of people voicing their opposition, the City Council approved $1.3 million in opening-day purchases Tuesday night.

“It sounds like they don’t pay any attention to what speakers say,” Richard McNally said.

McNally confirmed that he did indeed place his name on the online petition.

← Back to 2011

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
42373
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 933 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [6 distinct/14 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Newhall, City Council]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Laura Dixon]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0