ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Our View: Prepare for change on July 1

Only three more months. They might be three long, noisy months, but it’s only three months. July 1 will come, and either we’ll have peace on Earth, or the world will end. One way or the other, it will be over.

The library brouhaha, that is.

At this stage, arguing the facts with the staunchest critics is about as futile as is their resistance. There’s no talking to them.

Come July 1, the Newhall, Valencia and Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy libraries will no longer be county libraries. They’ll be city libraries. That is the fact.

Clearly, some people don’t like that fact. We can’t tell you how many people don’t like that fact— but some people don’t.

Maybe the number is close to the 200 or so people who crowded the City Council Chambers, many in their red, union-provided, pro-county-library T-shirts, and voiced their opposition to the city takeover.

Maybe the number is closer to the 10,000 the critics claimed when they submitted a list of names that included some non-people (such as Fred Flintstone), some vocal city-library supporters (such as Berta Gonzalez-Harper), some deceased residents (such as Joel Wellcome) and according to one petition organizer, an unknown number of noncity residents.

For discussion’s sake, let’s go ahead and say that one-seventeenth of the city’s population, or 10,000 people, oppose the city library takeover. They can be divided into two camps.

The biggest camp consists of people who might be just like you — people who go to the library to check out a book, use the county library website to order a book from another county library, and fear — right or wrong — that they might lose their ability to do those things if their libraries are no longer run by the county.

The other camp, a much smaller but enormously louder group, consists of activists who scream about the “privatization” of our libraries.

This group disgraces itself by interjecting such a base falsehood into an otherwise honest discussion among reasonable people.

“Privatization” isn’t what these people say it is. “Privatization” refers to ownership. A “privatized” service is one that is owned an operated by a private company. Think AT&T or the Valencia Water Co.

When the city of Santa Clarita takes over its three libraries from the county of Los Angeles, they will be city libraries. The city will own them. The city will be responsible for them. The city will determine how they operate. They will be municipal libraries.

By definition, they will not be “privatized.”

Where did this group get this erroneous idea? Probably from the fact that the city has hired a contract firm called Library Systems and Services Inc., or LSSI — a private company that operates city and county libraries all over the country, to manage and staff the city’s libraries.

Our libraries will be no more “privatized” than the hundreds of other city services operated by contractors today.

Only 350 people are direct employees of the city of Santa Clarita, but thousands of people perform “city work.” Think trash collectors. Think bus drivers. Think landscapers. Think graphic artists and print-shop owners and bulk mailers who design and print and distribute the city’s printed matter.

The city doesn’t do these things, or hundreds of other things, “in house.” And yet, all of them are municipal services.

“But wait,” you say. “The libraries aren’t like trash pickup or buses. They’re too important to be handled by contractors.”

Oh, really? What about our police and fire services? They’re municipal services, too. The City Council is responsible for them and decides how they’ll operate. Does the city put people on its own payroll to patrol our streets and douse our fires?

No. It hires contractors.

Operationally, come July 1, our city libraries will be no different from other contract services.

What’s driving the “privatization” crowd? Good question. It would be easy to dismiss them as would-be protectors of county library union jobs. But that wouldn’t tell the whole story.

Many are the same political activists who criticize our conservatively run city at every turn and make all of the typical Big Government claims that have driven our state into a deep, dark hole.

They rail against hiring contractors to perform municipal functions, as if government workers are the only people who could possibly be accountable to their customers, the taxpaying public.

Never mind that contracting is a huge part of what has kept Santa Clarita in the black while cities and county agencies up and down California — including the Los Angeles County Public Library system — are bleeding red ink.

Can you imagine if the city suddenly decided to ditch all of its contractors and hire direct employees, with their municipal salary expectations and public-employee retirement obligations and union bargaining rights, to perform trash pickup and every other city service?

Big Government is the problem, not the answer. Big Government is the reason California can’t tax its way out of a $27 billion mess.

If we “governmentized” every service in Santa Clarita (to misuse a term the way the critics misuse “privatize”), we’d be broke in five minutes.

Instead, this city contains costs by leveraging the operating efficiencies that only the private sector can offer. LSSI’s personnel costs are 15-percent lower than the county’s, primarily because it has a private-retirement plan and doesn’t have to pay into the public-employee retirement fund.

The critics rail against “corporatism” and profiteering — even though the city’s library contract keeps profits in check.

They chastise LSSI’s 5-percent service charge for purchasing and cataloguing new books and materials — completely ignoring the fact that the county’s overhead for acquisition and cataloguing is 45 percent of the cost of materials ($198,930 to acquire and catalog $444,272 in materials).

That efficiency, or lack thereof, is the reason the city went down this road in the first place. Santa Clarita was contributing too much money for an insufficient amount of service.

Not that the critics will listen or care, but we offer you, dear reader, a quick refresher.

A few years ago, the city identified a need for increased library service in Santa Clarita. So it decided we needed a bigger, better library in Newhall. The county librarian said “yeah!” or words to that effect, and involved her staff — actually a contractor — in the planning process.

Then came time to build the thing. Instead of saying “yeah,” the county librarian said “no way.”

Bear in mind, libraries are supposed to be built and equipped with developer fees and library taxes — which are collected by the county.

So the city decided to bite the bullet and pay for the Newhall Library itself, as it did 10 years earlier, when the county said no to building a bigger, better library in Canyon Country.

Then came time to budget for the books in the big Newhall Library. Again the county librarian said, “no way.” And the city was blown away.

It was a shocker. It made no sense, at least not on paper. Santa Clarita is one of only five cities in the entire 51-city county library system that keep the rest of the library system afloat. It’s one of only five that generate more taxes for the county library system than the county spends on libraries here.

City taxpayers certainly contributed more than enough to the county to fill the new library with books. But no dice.

A few months later, we learned why. The county librarian reported to the board of supervisors that her agency anticipated a $22 million annual structural deficit. All things being equal, even with Santa Clarita and four other cities contributing more than their fair share, the county library system was broke to the tune of $22 million per year.

By the time her report was publicized, Santa Clarita had already decided to go its own way. The handwriting was on the wall. It had seen the county librarian cut services and eliminate operating days at other libraries.

Not only wouldn’t the county pay a dime to fill the new library with books; it was only a matter of time before the county cut back our own library services.

And it did. When the City Council voted to break from the county library system, the county decided it was in no rush to reopen the Canyon Country library, which had been closed for renovation. The county kept it closed a few months longer, saving the county nearly $1 million in operating expenses for the time it was shut — without so much as a thank-you note to Santa Clarita city taxpayers.

In fact, it blackmailed the city into ponying up before it would reopen the doors.

Santa Clarita is the largest city in Los Angeles County not to have its own library system. Come July 1, another city will have that distinction.

Come July 1, Santa Clarita taxpayers will no longer subsidize libraries in Bell and other far-flung places served by the County Library system, or its administrative staff.

Santa Clarita’s libraries will be furnished with books and materials that were listed in a database the county filed with the state, but didn’t actually exist at the Santa Clarita libraries.

Come July 1, Santa Clarita’s libraries will have new hours — more hours, not fewer hours, as 45 county libraries experienced last year.

Come July 1, Santa Clarita library patrons will be able to check out books and DVDs and download e-books and read reference materials and access a bigger collection and order books from libraries elsewhere.

Or they won’t.

We’ll know in three months.

← Back to 2011

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
42465
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,600 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 18 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_32_local
  • byline:staff_marker [Signal Editor; Signal Editorial]
  • text:valley_names [6 distinct/29 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Canyon Country, City Council, Valencia Water]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0