Since 2007, the city of Santa Clarita and the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corp. have hustled to compete with other cities to get designated as one of 42 California enterprise zones.
Gov. Brown’s budget proposal has threatened to eliminate enterprise zones. Since then, the Santa Clarita business community has made a vigorous case for preserving enterprise zones to benefit businesses and help create jobs.
I support Santa Clarita’s participation in the Enterprise Zone program, which we should use to our best advantage while it exists.
While enterprise zones are beneficial for many Santa Clarita businesses and workers, we can also view enterprise zones as a pilot program, demonstrating how lower tax rates can benefit businesses, workers and the state.
America has one of the highest corporate tax rates in the world at 35 percent, soon to increase to 39.6 percent. Adding to that, California has some of the highest tax rates in the country, with a state income-tax rate of 10.3 percent for top wage earners.
Illinois, another high-tax state, has a flat income tax rate of 5 percent — 50-percent less than California.
Let’s consider a simplified business scenario to see the economic effect of the “extra” 5.3-percent state tax.
“Sally,” a top earner, is the owner of an S-corporation with annual revenues of $50 million and a net income of $3 million. The California state tax alone is $309,000.
Let’s assume the tax rate was 5 percent, like in Illinois. Now Sally pays only $150,000 in state taxes on the earnings.
What happens to the extra $159,000? Well, Sally wants to grow her company and needs to hire more telemarketing sales people. For $159,000, she could hire five additional people, on commission with a base salary of $30,000 per year. Sally could create an earning opportunity for five new employees, to help her grow her business. Since Sally is in California, there are no tax savings, and those five new employees don’t get hired. There is no money for it.
But Sally’s business is in Santa Clarita. Enterprise zones to the rescue!
Not so fast.
An Enterprise Zone incentive is not the same as a tax cut. With enterprise zones, Sally’s company must hire first, an up-front expenditure. Sally must select her new employees from a limited labor pool, which may or may not contain the talent she is seeking.
There is a lot of complex compliance paperwork, so Sally hires a tax specialist to help, another up-front expenditure.
Eventually, Sally saves money by claiming the tax credit over the next five years.
All this assumes that Sally has the cash to take advantage of the enterprise zone, because if she has to borrow the money, she is not saving anything.
Why are businesses not hiring? Where are the jobs? In Sally’s case, high tax rates and government policies are hampering job creation and business growth, both bad for state tax revenue collection.
A tax cut would be better for business than enterprise zones. If state taxes were not so high, these zones would not be so necessary.
Are we settling for enterprise zones because there is virtually no hope of getting a tax cut? If we think that way, then continued high taxes are inevitable.
If the state is thriving, with a growing economy and low unemployment, then lower tax rates will actually result in more tax revenue. The converse is also true, where higher tax rates actually cause state-tax revenues to decrease.
Our state borders, like our city and county borders, are not sealed. Huge disparities in taxes cause movement of employees and businesses, from high-tax states to low-tax states.
After 50 years of high taxes causing capital and talent to flee, we are left with Detroit.
Should we keep enterprise zones? For the moment, yes. In the long run, no.
A state with vast natural resources and great human potential, California should be prosperous. Across-the-board tax cuts would unleash California potential by helping every business. Enterprise zones have helped prove the need for the tax cut.
Prospering businesses can grow by putting more people to work, and the state can collect more tax revenues.
State enterprise zones have distracted our community. We are squabbling over bread crumbs when we should be focused on protesting the egregious tax rates, excessive regulations and unfunded public pension liabilities.
Andy Pattantyus lives and works in Santa Clarita and is the President of Strategic Modularity Inc. Contact Andy at [email protected]
