Something very remarkable has been happening in the Opinion pages of The Signal recently. Gary Horton and I have been having a civil discourse on the proper role of government in regard to services, parks and social structure.
There has been no name-calling, insults, or innuendo. I respect Horton’s opinions and I believe that he respects mine. It proves that folks with differing political views can share ideas in a calm and rational way. This is as it should be.
Sacramento should take a look at these columns.
In our capital, the vast chasm between views is helping to fuel the looming crisis. Our elected officials must find a path forward that works for the majority of the state.
Unfortunately, I think the right has been pushed into this uncompromising position by the radical left (and I do not include Horton in that group). Over the years, conservatives were willing to go along with the status quo as long as the state was healthy. In retrospect, this was a poor strategy that has helped contribute to the mess. Shame on us.
Now, the right has drawn battle lines and the left have only themselves to thank. However, the uncompromising nature of the left is now being reflected in a rejuvenated right — why are we so surprised?
Frankly, I’d be willing to go for the tax extensions if we could get real reform in Sacramento, like the removal of collective bargaining rights from public employee unions, the ending of “pension spiking” by state employees before retirement, and the outright purchasing of elected officials by special interest groups.
But getting back to the philosophical discussion on these Opinion pages, Horton cited an indignant Signal writer who said “if organized religion is so much better than government and is indeed putting forth the resources, why aren’t people choosing church-based social, welfare and medical services over government services?”
The answer is simple. Look at your paycheck. How much is removed in taxes weekly from your earnings? 15 percent? 25 percent? 35 percent? I know that when I get a bonus, I can expect to lose 45 percent right off the top. And where does that money go? Much of it goes to the services noted by Mr. Indignant.
So Americans are “forced” to support these government programs, which leaves little for anything else. But that isn’t the whole picture, is it?
I find it fascinating that Americans still find it in their hearts to give to churches, schools, pregnancy counseling centers and myriad charities. We are by far the most generous people on Earth.
When a disaster strikes a foreign country, who is always first in line to help? France? Italy? India? Nope. Look for the stupid Americans giving their money away.
What would happen if government stopped providing these social services and let the public take them back over? I would assert that fraud would drop dramatically, and people in need would still be helped. In fact, the cycle of poverty might be broken for many since the root causes for their predicament would be addressed, not merely the surface issues.
Many folks can’t even remember a time when government was not involved in things like health care. But not too long ago, that is the way it was.
The early Christian church looked around and realized that there weren’t very many places for sick people to get healed.
So they built white buildings staffed with ladies in funny hats who healed both body and soul. Hospitals like Holy Cross became commonplace.
Most churches, service organizations and social groups have active involvement in helping others and making the community a better place. I’d trust a church/mosque/synagogue, the Kiwanis, the Rotarians, the Boys & Girls Club, Boy Scouts of America or William S. Hart Baseball with a million dollars before I’d trust a government agency.
For someone to infer that the public cannot handle social services and that this is purely the bastion of government is simply ludicrous.
Government should be limited to public infrastructure (parks, roads, bridges, etc.), defense, civil order and the propagation of fair commerce. Unfortunately, our society has been inculcated to believe that individual Americans are powerless and that big government is the answer to all of our problems.
Nothing could be further from the truth. The more we rely on government to solve our problems and make life better for us, the more we slide away from what makes us Americans.
We are defined not by our government but who we are as a people and culture. Our government must never grow beyond the ability of the people to control it.
Steve Lunetta is a resident of Santa Clarita and can be reached at [email protected] .
