ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

It's the Law

Carl Kanowsky: Can Joe Camel balance the budget?

I don’t know how out of whack the state budget is — what, something like $360 gazillion? — but Gov. Jerry Brown has devised a unique way to at least reduce some of it. And all of this courtesy of our favorite cigarette mascot, Joe Camel.

It seems that in 1998 R.J. Reynolds, Joe Camel’s creator, entered into a consent decree on issues pertaining to public health concerns about smoking and the marketing of tobacco products to minors.

Our government, watching out for our collective health, had accused Big Tobacco — or BT for short — of targeting our kids by using cartoon characters to entice them to sample some of the product.

BT, including Reynolds, conceded nothing but agreed to halt the use of cartoons in its advertising.

Now, I don’t know about you, but I thought Joe Camel was pretty cool, even though he did hawk cancer sticks. Too bad we can’t use him to promote healthy eating habits or something more benign instead.

The definition of “cartoon” was very broad and included the classic, “the attribution of human characteristics to animals, plants or other objects, or the similar use of anthropomorphic technique.”

Consequently, Reynolds got in trouble in 2006 when it launched its “Camel Farm” and “Farm Rocks” campaigns. Don’t ask me — I have no idea what farm creatures have to do with tobacco, but then, I don’t get the appeal of “Mad Men” either.

Anyway, the state government, in the form of the then-attorney general, Jerry Brown, took umbrage at the media blitz and sued Reynolds for violating the consent decree.

Brown alleged that Reynolds had gone afoul when it used, “thousands of times,” flying tractors and radios and plants that grow televisions to hype their product. Again, the connection to cigarette smoking?

The court agreed that Reynolds had violated the decree a “relatively small amount of time.” And since Reynolds had already agreed in the consent decree not to do such advertising, the court reasoned there wasn’t much more for it to do including imposing any sanctions for Reynolds’ transgressions.

The state didn’t challenge this but did some creative lawyering on its own. Brown argued that since Reynolds was found to be in breach of the decree, it had lost the litigation and had to reimburse the state its attorney fees.

Apparently they asked for well over $1,000,000, but were awarded only $733,000. The state’s argument was that it was entitled to calculate its attorneys fees award based on “prevailing rates,” rather than what it actually spent. Reynolds went ballistic, saying that the state barely won, so it wasn’t entitled to anything. Both sides appealed.

The court of appeals punted on one issue and ruled on another. The court defined what being a “prevailing party” in a lawsuit is. And they told the trial court judge to read the definition and decide if the state really “prevailed” or not.

The appellate court then instructed the trial court that if it believed that the state actually was the prevailing party, it was entitled to “the number of hours reasonably expended multiplied by the reasonable hourly rate.”

What is a “reasonable rate? “The reasonable hourly rate is that prevailing in the community for similar work.”

I know that some of my colleagues charge upward of $750 an hour or more. Is that the relevant “community” that should be considered? The court of appeals left that up to the trial court.

So the state and Joe Camel are headed back to the original judge to ask him to revisit his decision in light of what the court of appeals had to say.

On behalf of all taxpayers, I’m rooting for Brown and his replacement, Kamala Harris, to hit a home run and force Reynolds to help us reduce the state’s red ink.

Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates is an attorney in the Santa Clarita Valley. He may be reached by email at [email protected] . Kanowsky’s column represents his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal. Nothing contained herein shall be or is intended to be construed as providing legal advice.

← Back to 2011

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
43059
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 686 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_25_local
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Santa Clarita]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Carl Kanowsky]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0