It is, as one observer put it, a strange business model.
And while Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital is not a for-profit business, it still must follow a business model with payroll to meet, 24-hour-a-day facilities to operate, services to provide and patients to care for.
Failure to perform at peak is not an option.
And the structure, as hospital officials explained during a recent visit to The Signal Editorial Board, is very complicated.
President and CEO Roger Seaver described the hospital’s leadership team as a “three-legged stool” of medical staff, administrators and board members.
* The Medical Executive Committee, a group of 11 doctors — five of whom are elected by 84 physicians with voting privileges — makes the medical decisions that directly affect the roughly 387 doctors practicing at Newhall Memorial. It oversees several physician committees.
The committee reports to the board of directors, but doctors at Newhall Memorial, as anywhere, are accountable to peers and boards within their professions — and ultimately to their patients. They are not, and under California law cannot be, employees of the hospital.
* The administration deals with day-to-day operations of the hospital — everything from parking issues to the gift shop to quality of care provided to administration of the employees it does have, including some 550 nurses. It also reports to the board of directors.
* The board of directors focuses on the business end of hospital operations to ensure the facility stays financially sound. It consists of 14 volunteers, including one executive, four physicians and nine community leaders.
This group reports directly to the community — as, ultimately, do the other two.
This structure of complex accountability is being squeezed by changes imposed by rapidly advancing technology and demands from government-regulated health care.
The shift from paper to electronic records has changed job descriptions for many workers. And as with any change, there’s opposition — push-back from those who like things the way they were.
That’s just one way technology has changed the way hospital workers do their jobs.
And like other hospitals across the country, Newhall Memorial is under increasing pressure to become what is called an evidence-based purveyor of medicine.
A benign-sounding title, certainly. But many physicians are unhappy with the new system, saying that it, in essence, takes away the soul and personal touch of the doctor-patient relationship.
Yet, because the hospital has to work within government-regulated health care demands, it must adopt the practice of evidence-based medicine.
These and many other challenges face the people who make up the three legs of the stool. That conflict is inherent in this situation is not surprising.
But we see signs of negotiation, of compromise and of moving forward.
Registered nurses’ demands have been heard and the “team nursing” program to which they objected is being phased out.
Doctors — who issued a no-confidence vote against other hospital leadership a few months ago — will enter mediation with administrators and board members next weekend. We call on the parties involved to negotiate in good faith with the goal of arriving at agreement, not fomenting dissent.
It won’t be easy to overcome the many difficulties posed by separate roles and sometimes differing goals.
But we believe each of the three parties will keep in mind the ultimate goal — the good of the community and the care of patients in need — and act accordingly.
