ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· archive.signalscv.com, Wayback capture

Right Here, Right Now! · By Tom Pattantyus

Andy, Tom Pattantyus: State tax rates stifle business growth, part 2

Are California “enterprise zones,” with their tax incentives, really the answer?

Tax breaks for businesses are but one aspect of the decision for a business to either stay in California, or leave for another state. High business taxes may not be the only problem. Conceivably, high personal-income taxes, high property taxes and high real estate prices may also prompt established businesses to flee California or cause new businesses to form in less expensive states.

We have looked up some taxation rates in South Dakota, Texas, Nevada, Michigan, New York and California and contrasted them with the April 2011 unemployment rates.

The first three states are low-tax states; Michigan is average; and New York and California are very-high-tax states.

The state and local tax rates in Nevada are as low as in Texas, so the root causes of high Nevada unemployment are not high taxes. Unemployment and tax rates are also weakly correlated in Michigan, but are strongly correlated in New York and California.

Business tax rates are only one factor of business-friendliness. Personal-income taxes, real estate taxes and real estate prices are also critical, because employees must live somewhere and must be able to support themselves.

How much of their paycheck does an employee get to keep? This is not a small question.

A professional contemplating an interstate transfer is going to take a good hard look at tax rates and living expenses. A better-paying job may actually yield a lower standard of living. Because these factors affect the availability of talent, some businesses in the expensive states have difficulty attracting new employees and are forced to relocate to less-expensive states.

The U-Haul and moving-van rates tell the story in one sentence: The rental rates moving out of California are generally much higher than in the opposite direction.

So what is the real problem? Let’s consider the factual numbers in the table shown.

Both Texas and California have a budget shortfall, and similar levels of debt. The big difference between the two states is the ratio of spending to gross state product.

To close this gap, states can: 1) raise more revenue by raising tax rates; 2) raise more revenue by increasing the gross state product, or GSP; or 3) cut spending.

Compared to Texas, California has a spending problem, which is quickly translating into a debt problem. Gov. Jerry Brown and the state of California propose to close the gap with more taxation. In January, Texas decided on budget cuts to bring spending in line with revenues.

States cannot expect a substantial bailout from Washington. The high-tax states will exacerbate their debt problems by increasing tax rates. Higher tax rates, either business or personal, are a business repellent, and will hurt the gross state product. Thus, raising taxes is not a long-term solution.

For any state to climb out of a financial hole, budget cuts and increased business activities are essential. Budget cuts bring spending in line with the gross state product. Increased business activity leads to increased GSP. More GSP, taxed at the same rate, brings more revenue.

To a business, taxes are simply an expense, and are passed on to the customer, if competition allows it. An individual cannot pass it along.

The equation is simple: gross minus taxes minus housing determines how much is left to live on. If disposable income is too small, then California businesses cannot attract talent from out of state, and may have to relocate just to be able to hire from the national labor pool.

In short, California has a spending problem and a personal tax-rate problem, neither of which are solved by the enterprise zones.

Andy Pattantyus lives and works in Santa Clarita and is the president of Strategic Modularity Inc. Tom Pattantyus is a retired electronic engineer. Contact Andy at [email protected] and Tom at [email protected] .

← Back to 2011

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
44507
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
archive.signalscv.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 637 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • page:ad_target_section_33
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Santa Clarita]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Andy Pattantyus]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0