Holly and Mark Gonzales were elated when their adoption attorney called one Friday night in February with a potential match: a 34-year-old woman due to deliver twin girls the same week.
A self-described single mother of three from Kansas, Kristy Bennett said she couldn’t afford to keep the babies and was looking for the right couple to adopt them.
For the Canyon Country couple, who’d tried for four years to have children and spent more than $120,000 on in vitro fertilization treatments, legal fees and expenses for two potential birth mothers over the past four years, the call was a sudden glimmer of hope.
Thirty minutes after their first phone call that weekend, the single mother sent Holly Gonzales a text saying, “I think you’re going to be great parents to the twins.”
“Twin girls — we were just ecstatic,” Holly Gonzales recounted.
Nonetheless, she said, their adoption facilitator warned the couple not to rush into anything until Bennett completed a full background screening.
Days later, after the expectant mom made several requests to the couple’s adoption attorney for cash to help cover rent, an unpaid gas bill and other basics, the attorney called with crushing news – there were no medical records of Bennett.
“Her story started to unravel,” Mark Gonzales remembered.
By then, the Canyon Country couple was busy readying a nursery, settling on names and picking out infant-sized car seats, Holly Gonzales recalled.
Even after the Gonzaleses cut ties with the woman, she sent them some 100 texts, many asking for cash to help her pay bills.
On the day the babies were supposedly born, another text came with a photo of two newborn girls and a message chiding the couple for not being there.
Later, the Gonzaleses heard from investigators that Bennett – whose real name is Roxanne Janel Jones – had been arrested on suspicion of wire fraud and identity theft.
The arrest came just moments after Jones was exposed as a scam artist on a televised undercover sting prompted by a CBS News employee who also claims to have been defrauded by the woman.
Police have since confirmed that Jones wasn’t pregnant and has conned up to a dozen other would-be parents into wiring money, Holly Gonzales said.
In April, Jones was charged with 12 counts of wire fraud and identify theft and could face up to 22 years in federal prison and a $500,000 fine if convicted on all counts, according to a CBS News report.
“Our main concern was trying to get this girl off the streets so she couldn’t do this to another couple,” said Mark Gonzales, noting that the charges give him some sense that justice has been served.
Though the couple was rattled by the experience at first, Holly Gonzales said they haven’t given up the search for a birth mother, nor their dreams of building a family.
“As excruciating as it is, we’re still going,” she said, a determined look in her eyes. “I’m still hopeful.”
The Gonzaleses’ adoption facilitator, who asked to remain anonymous, explained that while adoption fraud is nothing new, women like Jones are the exception to adoptions.
“Most girls do this for the right reason and are doing it in the best interest of their child, but there’s 1 percent of girls who use it for fraud,” she said. “That’s why we screen so hard before jumping in.”

