The last three seasons have all been unsuccessful for Foothill League baseball teams in the CIF-Southern Section Division I playoffs.
Look at Tuesday's results - Valencia and Hart both exited the playoffs in the second round.
Before that, West Ranch lost its wild-card game.
It begs the question - Is it time for a change?
Half of the Foothill League's head coaches agree that the six teams should move down to Division II.
"I think as a league as a whole, I don't think we're a Division I league. I think we're more of a Division II league," said Valencia High baseball head coach Jared Snyder. "We have six schools in the district - that's a whole lot different than other districts."
Said Saugus head coach John Maggiora about the Foothill being better suited for Division II: "I've thought that for a while."
The Foothill League's teams made a switch to Division I, seen as the most powerful and competitive division in the Southern Section, in 2004.
That was the last time a Santa Clarita Valley team was in a semifinal.
Through the first couple of years, there was mixed postseason success, but since 2009, the Foothill has struggled in the postseason.
Since 2009, the Foothill League is 4-11 in the Division I postseason, but the more glaring fact is that no local team has made it past the second round of the playoffs.
According to Thom Simmons, CIF-SS director of communications, the CIF groups teams in divisions by competitive equity, enrollment and geography, with the No. 1 reason being competitive equity.
It's a fair argument to say that the Foothill League just hasn't been competitive in Division I recently.
They're not the only league.
The Pacific View League has been worse at 3-11.
But coaches in the Foothill League say it's definitely a different ballgame in the Santa Clarita Valley since Golden Valley and West Ranch joined the fray in 2007.
"I think now having the six teams in the Santa Clarita Valley, there's some parity," said West Ranch head coach Casey Burrill, who before coming to West Ranch was the head coach at Saugus. "All the teams are real competitive. They have their share of great athletes. There's not these huge, superpowerhouse teams put together in our valley."
In 2008, the second season of all Santa Clarita Valley teams in the Foothill League, Hart and Valencia both reached the quarterfinals. But one has to look at the talent of at least one of those teams - Hart - and see why it made it so far.
Hart's starting pitchers were Michael Montgomery, currently the Kansas City Royals' top pitching prospect, and Trevor Bauer, who is currently at UCLA and considered a possible top-10 pick in this year's Major League Baseball First-Year Player Draft.
Talent like that doesn't come around very often.
Three coaches in the Foothill League believe that it should stay in Division I - Golden Valley's Scott Drootin, Canyon's Adam Schulhofer and Hart's Jim Ozella.
"I think Division I is pretty darn challenging. I like the challenge, I'll leave it at that," Ozella said. "What is better for us as a league? It's a matter of opinion. It's not to downplay Division II. Division II's pretty darn challenging as well."
Foothill coaches know that others would perceive a move down a division as a wave of the white flag.
But Burrill, for one, looks at the facts.
The success hasn't been great, the competition level is perceived as being higher in Orange County (where three of the top four seeds in this year's Division I tournament are from) and there is the parity situation.
On top of that, the Santa Clarita Valley has a high school in Castaic on the horizon which could water down the Foothill League even more.
Drootin said he wants his team to play against the best competition.
One solution he said he has brought up at a league meeting - and one that Snyder said he brought up in the past - is shrinking the league season from 15 games to 10 games, like what the Foothill does in softball.
That would allow the Foothill teams to play more tournament games against the stronger Division I teams and make them more battle-tested come playoff time.
Ozella said another reason his team was successful in that 2008 postseason was that the Indians played more Saturday tournament games than usual, allowing Hart to develop a third pitcher and get more guys playing time, resulting in more depth.
Transportation could be an issue because of the budget crunch these local schools are under, but Drootin suggests that there are ways around that.
He said if the lower-level teams start their games at 4 p.m., thus asking parents to transport their kids to games, it would give varsity teams more money for transportation.
Foothill coaches have mentioned that there is a more fair way to play in the playoffs, Division I or not. That's to turn the playoffs into a double-elimination tournament.
That is on the table with the CIF-SS.
"Yes, a proposal has been made for a first read in October and a vote in January to have a double-elimination tournament up to the semifinals and a best two-out-of-three in the semifinals and finals," Simmons said. "This past Thursday, the CIF-SS Executive Committee voted to not support that idea."
The Foothill League will play in Division I in 2012.
Simmons said the Playoff Groupings Committee will re-evaluate its divisions prior to next season for the 2013 and 2014 baseball seasons.
For a valley so rich in baseball tradition, there is something missing - championships.
The last time a Foothill team made a division final was 2002.
That year, Canyon lost to Villa Park (also now in Division I) in the Division II final.
The only Foothill League team to ever win a CIF-SS title was Hart in 1999.
That was a Division II championship.
