The cadre of six clan members dutifully erupted into cheers, which the recent graduate found hard to hear on the stage — as he concentrated on not falling down the stairs that led to ground level — during an attempt at a graceful exit in the unfamiliar robe and mortarboard.
Had four years really passed this quickly since this same young man crossed the stage at College of the Canyons, graduating from Valencia High School?
Did he really seem much older and mature than four years of education would indicate on the stage at Rimac Field at the University of California, San Diego, in La Jolla — fortified by living on his own, a semester abroad in Europe and a nearly three-year relationship with Roxanne, an outstanding and beautiful, young woman the Myers clan adores.
Graduation season once again upon us, the media provides the public with the usual range of stories of hope, promise and triumph over adversity, though tinged with a sense of sourness in the teeth of high unemployment and a poor job market for graduates, with many opting continuation into graduate school or supporting themselves with jobs that do not require a bachelor’s degree, but will support a modest young lifestyle until something better turns up. With a graduate in the mix, I cannot myself resist a moderate amount of navel gazing; so here goes.
First we examine the issues surrounding college completion rates: Nationally, 32 percent of entering freshmen will complete their bachelor’s degree within four years of entering college. The six-year graduation rate stands at roughly 56 percent.
(The U.C. system schools of Berkeley, UCLA, and San Diego enjoy better four-year graduation rates of 56 percent to 66 percent, and six-year rates of 85 percent to 93 percent.)
Many reasons exist for the slow or no completion, primarily that large cadres of students, particularly in those public systems that admit 90-plus percent of their applicants, endure huge freshmen and sophomore dropout rates with students that never return.
For example, the University of Nebraska, which must by law admit a graduate of a Nebraska high school, loses 35 percent of its entering freshmen after two years. Also, some argue that high school education ill prepares students for college, which leads to low credit velocity, since they must continuously drop and retake courses.
Second, we examine the issues surrounding the eruption of “for-profit” higher education, those primary buyers of daytime television advertising.
Attending law school in the 1980s at Drake University, my classmates and I joked that if we failed the bar exam, we could always, “Go to Lincoln Tech, and work on the big rigs.”
These primary consumers of federally guaranteed student-loan money generally come from the lower socioeconomic classes, and no longer confine themselves to trades, such as diesel- and gasoline-engine mechanics, branching out to accredited institutions, such as the University of Phoenix and DeVry Institute. These institutions account for only 9 percent of undergraduate and graduate students in the United States, but consume 25 percent of total Pell Grant and federally guaranteed loan money, and account for an astounding 44 percent of student-loan defaults.
To that end, the Department of Education proposed the gainful employment rule that provides that any institution will lose access to federal aid if they fail to meet at least one of the following metrics:
Thirty-five percent of graduates with loan obligations reducing their principle by at least $1 per year (turning this on its head, institutions can qualify if 65 percent of graduates are in full default).
Annual loan payments of a typical graduate do not exceed 30 percent of total discretionary income; or annual loan payments do not exceed 12 percent of total income.
Unfortunately, this constitutes a politically sensitive matter, even though it seems rather easy to meet these goals. Read the primary contributors to our own Congressman Howard “Buck” McKeon’s, R-Santa Clarita, re-election campaigns, when he led the House Education and Workforce Committee to know why.
And finally, certain people, probably still on the margins, question the usefulness of any college education, stating that graduates do not seem to make marked improvements in writing or critical thinking skills from their high school years, merely taking the same tests from high schools with more difficult material and brighter classmates.
But for what it is worth, we are proud of Chip, and also give a shout-out to Valencia High School, where all the students who matriculated into the University of California, San Diego, Eleanor Roosevelt College in that fall of 2007 did complete their bachelor’s degrees in four years.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident. “Myers’ Musings” runs Sundays in The Signal.
