A local environmental group is suing the city of Santa Clarita and the developers of a Canyon Country mixed-use housing project that straddles the Santa Clara River, saying the city didn’t properly weigh the project against the state’s Environmental Quality Act.
The Vista Canyon project consists of more than 1,000 homes and almost 1 million square feet of commercial office and retail space on 185 acres situated across Highway 14 from Canyon Country Park and west of Sand Canyon.
Vista Canyon and its environmental review were approved by the Santa Clarita City Council in May.
The Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment, known as SCOPE, filed the lawsuit in June. It says the project would encroach on the Santa Clara River floodplain and discharge chloride from a water treatment plant that’s part of the project.
Jim Backer, president of JSB Development, Vista Canyon’s developer, said the river width proposed under the project is twice that of most of the other portions of the river in the Santa Clarita Valley.
As for chloride, SCOPE President Lynne Plambeck said the city’s environmental review of the Vista Canyon project didn’t require the project to clean the water to the state’s specifications, leaving the burden of chloride cleanup to the taxpayers.
Backer said the project has undergone five years of review. He said he was disappointed but not surprised by the lawsuit.
“The river received a huge amount of attention,” Backer said. “(The project has) been thoroughly analyzed. But some people don’t like those results.”
The city is preparing a response to the lawsuit, Backer said. It could take anywhere from a couple of months to a year to sort out.
Whether the lawsuit affects the city’s annexation efforts in the area is unclear. The city is pursuing the largest annexation in its history, of some 3,250 acres including portions of the Sand Canyon and Jakes Way neighborhoods of Canyon Country, as well as Vista Canyon, which would provide the sales tax generation that would pay for the added infrastructure.
As with Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital’s expansion, Plambeck said, the city has missed an opportunity to ask for more strict environmental controls. SCOPE pursued a lawsuit in that case, too; it lost.
An appeals court in that case said SCOPE didn’t exhaust its administrative possibilities before pursuing litigation. Plambeck said the plaintiffs don’t expect the same problem this time around.
