Amid a half-dozen homes in Happy Valley a tennis court has sprung up with bright lights, a 10-foot-tall chain-link fence surrounding it and a second court used for volleyball.
Neighbors say the courts’ lights make it look like daytime in their own backyards, even at 10 p.m., and that use of the courts is very noisy.
Property manager David Schwartz denies their claims.
The tennis court is built in the large backyard of an 8th Street home. That yard abuts the backyards of several other homes.
Residents there say the courts are an eyesore. In addition to the tennis and volleyball courts, owners built a grass field on the property that on Thursday featured a soccer goal post and net.
Neighbors worry that the property manager will use the property to give commercial tennis lessons.
City code-enforcement officials served Schwartz a violation notice for the lights and warned him against using the property for commercial purposes about a month ago.
“From what we understand people have been getting tennis instruction day and night, using lights that do not have glare shields,” said Lisa Webber, the city’s planning manager. “Having a home-based business with customers coming to your home is not allowed, period. This has been communicated to David.”
The city is monitoring the property, watching for code infractions, day and night and on weekends, as they wait for Schwartz to bring the property into compliance, Webber said.
“The burden of proof is on the city to prove that the use of the property is not appropriate,” she said. “This is where it does become challenging.”
But the property owners have every right to build what they want on their property, Santa Clarita planners said, as long as they have the proper permits and the structure is five feet from neighboring property lines, which it is.
The courts can stay, but they can’t be used for commercial purposes, and neighbors must be shielded from the bright lights, Santa Clarita city planners say.
Neighbors complain
For the Losorelli family, a view that once included plenty of trees and the neighborhood beyond is now just a 10-foot chain link fence wrapped in black mesh and three banks of lights flanking the two courts, their lamps jutting about 15 feet in the air.
“Everybody that comes over says they can’t believe the city can’t do anything about it,” neighbor Rudy Losorelli said.
But that is the case, even in Happy Valley, which has one of the city’s special standards districts, Webber said. Such districts mainly affect aesthetic qualities in a neighborhood by limiting street lighting, adding trees and allowing fewer curbs and sidewalks — not governing land use.
“A special standards district doesn’t preclude someone from building a tennis court on a large property,” Webber said.
Trees and light guards
Schwartz has agreed to plant cypress trees along the perimeter of the property to act as a sound and light barrier, Webber said, as well as installing light guards.
Schwartz, who lives in Stevenson Ranch, said the property owners built the tennis court for personal use only, not for commercial use.
Schwartz said Friday that he was working to address the city’s concerns. He said he has installed glare shields on the lights, a few of which were visible Friday.
Neighbor Perry Manger said the worst part is the lights.
“It’s like the spaceship landing in (science-fiction movie) ‘Close Encounters (of the Third Kind),’” Manger said. “It’s just a massive amount of lights, and that’s only with two-thirds of the lights on.”
The mesh on the fencing should help with the light bleeding over to neighboring properties as well as the number of tennis balls flying into neighbors’ yards, Webber said.
