Today, I was watching my kids play in the front yard, when a lady walked up and asked, “Do you remember me? About seven months ago, I was collecting bottles and cans from the recycling bins, and you gave me lunch.”
She continued that she no longer collected from residents’ recycling bins — that a sheriff’s deputy stopped her, informing that she could be arrested for continuing to do so.
In any other culture, at any other point in history, poor folks creating self-sufficiency, making a living off discards, would be lauded: a shining point of ingenuity.
Yet, today, in Santa Clarita, poor people are marginalized. Why do we have a city ordinance against scavenging?
Here are the facts:
In 2010, the city collected 17,222 tons of mixed recyclables from its curbside collection program. This garnered the city the princely sum of $94,721, which was placed in the city’s general fund, having a total annual budget of $79 million.
In other words, the city earns a very negligible amount of money on recyclables. In fact, if scavengers were to pull every single recyclable out of curbside Dumpsters, the city would lose only 0.1199 percent of the general fund revenue.
According to World Bank, 2 percent of the population in Third World countries scavenges garbage to sustain their lives.
Even people here in the U.S. make a living by scavenging through trash. Witness the example of Yolanda and Rogelio Garcia who, for 21 years, collected recyclables throughout Los Angeles, and supported their three kids without government assistance.
Read about Mayor Mark-Paul Serafin, from Manlius Village, N.Y., who collected recyclables from residents’ curbside bins for more than 10 years, using the money to buy monthly medicine for his pet Labrador.
Scavenging improves the economy for the disadvantaged, and helps to alleviate poverty. Repurposing trash has always been a staple of frugality, prudence and survival.
Some officials consider scavenging as a gateway crime to illegal drugs, identity theft and more. But hear this: Nobody is baby-sitting your trash once it hits the curb. Check out U.S. Supreme Court case California v. Greenwood, in which a convicted drug dealer challenged the legality of a search warrant issued based on evidence cops gathered from his curbside trash.
Justice White, who authored the majority opinion, wrote:
“It is common knowledge that plastic garbage bags left on or at the side of a public street are readily accessible to animals, children, scavengers, snoops and other members of the public. Moreover, respondents placed their refuse at the curb for the express purpose of conveying it to a third party.”
Greenwood lost his appeal, and his drug conviction stood. Does rummaging through trash lead to drug abuse, or does it catch drug dealers? That’s irony, right there. And a huge contradiction in the law.
Others believe that scavenging leads to theft of personal belongings.
Listen, you leave your stuff out, anyone walking down the street could steal it. Shall we, then, outlaw nonresidents walking down residential streets? Do you see how silly the reasoning is?
What are the real reasons for this ordinance? Is it illegal to be poor? Is it illegal to survive on another person’s trash?
If folks are coming onto your property, then call the Sheriff’s Department for trespassing. If folks are leaving behind a mess, call the law enforcement for littering. If the noise is bothering you, call in a disturbance of the peace. But simply rummaging through garbage bins that are left on the curb? Puh-leez.
And if you just don’t like to look at poor people in your neighborhood, maybe you should stick your head a little deeper into the sand.
Here’s the deal: It is your trash. Trash , get it? You are done with it. It no longer has value to you. You don’t even want to take the time to cash in on the recycling yourself. Give it up. Are we so damn possessive that we have to micro-manage our trash?
The poor are here in Santa Clarita. You cannot legislate them away. And pity the man who hoards even the crumbs that fall from his wealthy table.
15.44.723 Scavenging: It is unlawful for anyone other than the owner of the recyclable materials or an authorized recyclable materials collector to remove recyclable materials or recyclable solid wastes placed for collection in containers labeled for use in connection with a recycling program sponsored by the city or city-authorized solid waste enterprise. (Ord. 09-4 § 1, 4/28/09)
The ordinance was passed as part of the consent calendar, without discussion, and the only input sought was from local haulers.
Lori Rivas, amateur opinionator and recipient of zero awards, lives across the border in Newhall, and is hoping that the voices in her head will bother you, too.
