VAN NUYS — Two retired sheriff’s officials and a retired county prosecutor took the stand Wednesday in the hearing that could set Edward Contreras free. Contreras is serving a life sentence for the 1995 murder of a Santa Clarita man.
Contreras, now 40, has sought the help of the California Innocence Project to reverse his guilty conviction.
Contreras and former friend Scott Taylor were both found guilty of murder and lying in wait for the 1995 killing of Frederick Walker.
Walker was beaten to death and then his body was dismembered and discarded in Bouquet Canyon.
Two key witnesses — the only people there when Walker was killed — recanted the testimony they gave in the 1997 trial during hearing dates last month before Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Gregory Dohi in Van Nuys Courthouse West.
On Wednesday, Innocence Project attorney Mario Conte worked to bolster his argument that witness Lisa Garringer, now 40, lied under pressure from detectives.
Conte read from transcripts and asked former Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Deputy Jon Jones why he and sheriff’s
Detective John Greenwood didn’t ask follow-up questions when Garringer and her mother, Rosalyn Blaser, suggested they didn’t think Contreras had as much to do with Walker’s death as Taylor did.
The sheriff’s officials stopped the tape shortly after Garringer, then 16, and her mother volunteered that information. They didn’t ask what they meant, Conte said.
Jones admitted neither he nor Greenwood asked about their comments further.
Justin Brooks, director of the Innocence Project, said attorneys for Contreras are trying to build the case that deputies worked to develop their first theory — that both men had killed Walker — rather than explore all possibilities.
Garringer was a scared teen with an immigrant mother on parole, and she went along with that story out of fear, Brooks said.
Michelle Walker, the victim’s sister, doesn’t see it that way. Walker’s family hopes Contreras stays in prison.
“He’s never apologized or shown any remorse,” Walker said.
The habeas corpus hearing is scheduled to continue late this month. If such a hearing is successful for the defendant, the judge would order the conviction reversed, Brooks said.
Prosecutors could re-prosecute, but that typically doesn’t happen since there isn’t new evidence, he said.
