A list of historic sites that property owners can opt out of ... or opt into.
That's the new proposal city planners unveiled to a group of residents during a community meeting at the Santa Clarita Activities Center on Thursday night.
The proposal will be presented to the Santa Clarita Planning Commission next month.
The city's efforts to create a list of historic properties to preserve - a move that would limit owners' options for remodeling or demolition - has resulted in a prolonged public outcry.
At a near loss of options, city planners have taken into account much of the vociferous public opinion they've received and come up with a new historic preservation ordinance that a property owner would voluntarily opt into.
That same property owner could then opt out of the ordinance by writing a letter to the city.
The problem with this proposal is the perks that go with historic designation.
Owners of properties that are deemed historic would be granted free city permits through a streamlined process.
As proposed, there's nothing stopping a property owner from opting in to the historic designation, reaping the rewards of free and expedited permits, then opting out again, said Duane Harte, a Newhall Redevelopment Committee member.
"That's like getting it handed to you on a platter," Harte said.
The proposal also negates the entire purpose of a historic preservation ordinance - preserving properties that have historic value, said Pat Saletore, executive director of the Santa Clarita Valley Historical Society.
"This is a waste of time," Saletore said. "This is just a bunch of nonsense."
Some residents were more open to the proposal, saying that having an opt-out ordinance would mean residents would be more likely to opt in, since they wouldn't be held to preservation forever if they didn't want to be.
Other residents said the whole idea of a historic preservation ordinance doesn't work in Santa Clarita, where private property rights are revered.
"If you want them preserved, then buy them and preserve them," said Tim Crissman, chairman of the Old Town Newhall Association.
