The city’s landscape maintenance district was thrust into the local spotlight again this month as revisions presented to the Santa Clarita City Council riled neighborhoods anew.
The district, which blankets about three-quarters of the city, is made up of about 40 zones. Property owners in each zone pay fees of different amounts based on the maintenance costs for the public landscaping in their area.
For example, property owners in the Northbridge community pay $792 per parcel annually. Northpark property owners pay $392 per parcel. Property owners in a proposed downtown Newhall zone would pay $72 annually.
On Tuesday night, the Santa Clarita City Council will consider accepting the results of the latest ballot, which passed 56 percent to 44 percent, creating the Newhall zone and changing the rates in several other zones.
For some, the price disparity between zones juxtaposes harshly with the voting manner. Changes to the district are made by vote, and property owners in all the affected zones cast ballots in a single election, with all ballots counted together.
The ballots are weighted: the votes of property owners who would pay more are “worth” more, and vice versa. So a single Newhall vote is “worth” less than a single Northbridge vote.
The recent ballot results can be broken down another way: $1,145,974 voted “yes”; $901,745 voted “no.”
The idea is that a property owner who would be more greatly affected should have more say in the matter, city officials say.
But some residents are dissatisfied with the district and its balloting process, saying the voting pits neighbor against neighbor. Some Newhall residents say they didn’t stand a chance at saving their $72 when Northbridge residents were more than happy to approve the changes, which would lower their fee by almost $14 a year.
The Signal took a few minutes with Deputy City Manager Darren Hernandez, who oversees the district, to discuss the landscape maintenance district, how it came to be and why it works the way it does.
Signal: Why have a landscape maintenance district at all?
Hernandez: The LMD pays for the maintenance of landscaping and beautification enhancements for specific neighborhoods.
Signal: Why not have everyone pay the same amount, or the same percent of their property tax, and have the city just maintain all the landscaping without a complex formula and zoning?
Hernandez: State law requires that the assessment charged to a property for maintaining enhancements must be proportional to the special benefit conferred on the parcel. Each neighborhood zone in the LMD has different and unique landscaping and beautification enhancements, and the costs to maintain those vary. The rate structure for each zone is intended to make sure the assessments to each property are proportional to the benefits and costs.
Signal: Isn’t this really just a hidden tax?
Hernandez: No, for two reasons. First, the LMD assessment is a specific line item on the property tax bill, so every property owner can see exactly what they are paying, so it isn’t hidden at all. Second, assessments fund improvements that provide a specific special benefit to properties, while taxes are not required to have a connection between the amount you pay and the benefit you receive.
Signal: What do the fees pay for?
Hernandez: In many neighborhoods, the LMD pays for landscape and beautification enhancements in the public right-of-way or easements. These vary from area to area, but generally include maintaining parkways, side panels, slopes, entry monuments, paseo trails and street trees.
Signal: What’s the difference between homeowners association fees and the landscape maintenance district fees?
Hernandez: The difference varies from area to area, but in many areas the LMD handles all of the landscaping and beautification in public areas and the HOA maintains amenities such as pools, tennis courts and clubhouses. There is no redundancy.
Signal: Why do some residents pay more to be in the district and other residents pay less?
Hernandez: The assessment amounts vary because the costs of maintaining the landscape and beautification enhancements vary from area to area.
Signal: How does the city decide when to amend the district with annexations or detachments?
Hernandez: Areas are annexed into the LMD when landscaping, and beautification enhancements are proposed that would require ongoing city maintenance. It would not be fair for some property owners to pay for the enhancements in their neighborhood through an LMD assessment while other areas get enhancements without being part of the LMD.
Signal: Who pays for the landscape maintenance in areas of the city that are not in the district?
Hernandez: Areas not within the LMD either have landscape and beautification enhancements handled by an HOA or there are no enhancements. We don’t use general city revenue to fund landscape and beautification enhancements. If areas want landscape and beautification enhancements, they must become part of the LMD.
