One day after it was reported that Canyon football forfeited a victory over Golden Valley because it played an ineligible player, the Cowboys now have to forfeit a 51-28, Oct. 14 victory to Saugus.
Because Saugus gains a Foothill League victory, it now finishes at 4-1 and claims a share of the Foothill League title with Valencia.
Canyon, though, would likely not have to forfeit the Golden Valley game because of CIF-Southern Section Blue Book rule 500.2.1.
That rule states: “In the case where it is determined that an ineligible player competed due to the failure of the school administration to submit the proper paper work which would have granted immediate eligibility with no restrictions, i.e., transfer eligibility with no restrictions, the school would only be forced to forfeit the initial game won or tied that the student in question played.”
The player in question, a former Golden Valley High student, transferred to Canyon before the school year because of boundary changes. That player’s little brother is now slated to attend Canyon High School.
The player was discovered to have played in the Nov. 10, 48-21 Canyon victory over Golden Valley.
Golden Valley administration notified Canyon High administration that the player’s transfer paperwork might not have been finished.
That turned out to be the case as the interdistrict transfer paperwork was completed, but the CIF-SS did not give final approval on it.
Canyon High head football coach Rich Gutierrez said the CIF-SS didn’t receive the proper information on the transfer.
On Tuesday, it was found out that the player played on one kickoff in the Saugus game.
Canyon principal Bob Messina called Saugus principal Bill Bolde to inform him of the violation.
Canyon forfeited the game, which in turn gave Saugus a share of the Foothill League title.
“We’re not interested in putting a banner in the gym,” Bolde said. “If our record is 4-1, so be it. It’s not a co-championship in our eyes.”
But the Saugus victory now changes the Foothill standings.
Valencia defeated Saugus 35-0 last Friday, meaning the Vikings would be the No. 1 seed from the Foothill League in the Northern Division playoffs.
Saugus would be No. 2 and Canyon would be No. 3.
The Cowboys, by virtue of their No. 2 spot, were afforded a home game in the first round of the playoffs, as they host Palmdale on Friday.
Saugus will travel to play Highland on Friday.
Bolde said Messina contacted the CIF-SS office and its officials put the issue of who would get a home game into Saugus’ hands.
A message was left on Messina’s cell phone that he did not return.
The CIF-SS office was closed by the time The Signal learned of the situation.
Bolde said he met with Centurions head coach Jason Bornn and assistant principal Rich Bahr and all three decided to leave the games as is.
“We don’t want to disrespect Palmdale or Highland. We’ll take the away game,” Bolde said. “It doesn’t bode well for any of us in the valley to upset anybody 20 miles away.”
Bolde was sympathetic to Canyon, specifically its players and Gutierrez, a Saugus High graduate who by all accounts did not intentionally violate any rules.
“I can’t say enough about (Gutierrez),” Bolde said. “I enjoyed him as a student, and I’m enjoying seeing him as a leader in this community.”
Bolde said he still recognizes Canyon as the co-champions.
Gutierrez told The Signal on Monday that he was under the impression that he didn’t have to go any further with paperwork on the player, but did say he may have misinterpreted the process because of the boundary change.
Gutierrez was insistent that it wasn’t the player’s fault.
“He’s a good kid. I knew this was going to be tough,” Gutierrez said. “I don’t want this kid to carry this. It’s a game we play. He’s an innocent guy who came from another school. He’s a kid.”
Now for Golden Valley, if the rule is interpreted correctly, the Grizzlies now lose the game that was forfeited to them.
That would mean the Grizzlies have still lost all 29 Foothill games in their history.
Golden Valley’s final record is 1-9 overall and 0-5 in league.
Saugus is 7-3, 4-1 in league and Canyon is 8-2, 3-2 in league.
“Anything that comes across your table, you always have to make sure it’s above board, and if you have any questions, you make sure you go to CIF,” Gutierrez said on what was learned about the situation.
