Hart football will have five football players ineligible to play varsity football next year due to a violation of a CIF undue influence rule.
The William S. Hart Union High School District, Hart High and the CIF-Southern Section mutually agreed to the penalty after Hart administrators found out that there was a violation within the program.
Five current freshmen won’t be eligible to play at the varsity level next season and one sophomore, currently on the junior varsity team, will be ineligible to play varsity football for the Indians’ first four games next season.
No current varsity players will be penalized.
“There was no allegation of recruiting, there is nothing proven, there is no evidence to that,” said Hart varsity head coach Mike Herrington. “The reason it came about is because there is a CIF rule there and there has been a lot of investigation.”
There have been whispers for months that a group of players followed coaches Scott French and Deron White to Hart because they had previously played for the coaches at the youth level.
Hart High Principal Collyn Nielsen and Herrington wouldn’t comment on who the kids were.
They also wouldn’t comment on whether French and or White will return next season.
“This is not a Hart freshman football issue. This is a Hart District athletics issue,” Nielsen said. “We have club coaches on campus. We value their work. They are a great resource for us. I’m sure there are a number of situations across the district and Southern Section similar to ours.”
Nielsen said the school will now review whether any of its coaches who also coach outside of the high school have coached any kids in the past who have transferred into the school.
Hart District Superintendent Robert Challinor said he believed Hart did not intentionally violate any rules.
Coaches and administrators at different schools in the Santa Clarita Valley have speculated to The Signal as far back as September, though, that there was an intentional violation of the undue influence rule within the Hart freshman football program.
That rule, CIF-Southern Section Bylaw 510, states that “a student who has played for a coach at one school and chooses to follow a relocated coach to his new school is in violation of this rule, regardless of having proper intra-district transfer approvals filed. Under this rule, a student may receive sanctions including having restricted eligibility for one year or may re-enroll at the school of their residence. This rule also applies to players of youth sports clubs and teams where the student and family choose to continue with the same coach when the student enters high school.”
Herrington and Nielsen said they were unaware of any violation going back to September.
Nielsen said he was notified of the language of the rule two weeks ago, then an investigation began.
Those who have speculated about the violation pointed to a change of coaching staffs in the Hart program two years ago when Dan Cota, who was the Indians’ freshman coach for 17 years, was moved up to be the head junior varsity coach.
That, Hart critics argue, allowed former youth coach French to take over the freshman program, and also allowed White, another former youth coach, to join the program.
Herrington said two years ago his JV program needed stability after coaching mismatches within the program so he brought Cota up.
Herrington defends the French hiring by noting that French was on the JV coaching staff in 2009 and because of his experience and fit in the Hart program at the time, he was given the freshman head coaching job.
“As far as I’m concerned everything is fine in the program,” Herrington said.
