In the meltdown mess of the real estate mortgage market, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Federal Housing Administration took a look at the long list of condominium developments that were approved for the FHA-backed mortgage insurance on home loans — and their exposure.
There were so many complexes that had been approved for FHA loans that program officials were no longer sure which complexes were still eligible under the guidelines, said Nancy West, marketing and outreach specialist for FHA with the Santa Ana Homeownership Center.
Consequently, lenders were given 12 months to re-certify all projects that were approved in 2009, West said.
“By the end of 2010, FHA and HUD recognized there would be such an astronomical list of projects that would drop off the list, we allowed lenders an additional six months to re-certify projects,” West said.
Members of the Santa Clarita realty and loan industries say many of the condo complexes that once were FHA-approved no longer qualify — leaving Santa Clarita home sellers and homebuyers in the lurch.
Many projects had been approved in the past that no longer meet eligibility requirements, West said.
Lenders’ responsibility
The reason so many common-interest developments dropped off the list of being re-certified is because no lender brought a buyer or borrower to the table, she said.
But Andy Boron, a loan officer with Augusta Financial said that makes no sense.
The logic might apply to a lender backing a new condominium development, but not for an existing complex. And, of course, building in the housing industry has all but come to a complete stop in the past several years.
This puts the problem of the majority of Santa Clarita complexes not seeking re-certification in the past year back at square one for buyers, sellers, realtors and loan officers alike.
“The FHA took away our ability to do that (re-certify) when they eliminated our ability to get spot approval on an individual condo,” Boron said. “The complex itself, the Associations have to go through the process of getting approval or re-certified. The lender can’t do that for an entire complex.”
There are buyers all over the place that are FHA-qualified borrowers, looking at complexes they’re interested in buying but the complex itself is not approved, he said.
“We don’t have the ability any more; the documentation and the expense fall on the homeowners association,” Boron said.
The ability to secure spot approval on condos is out of the FHA’s hands, West said. It was eliminated by Congress under the Housing and Economic Recovery Act signed into law July 30, 2008.
There was no real guarantee that an individual condo property itself was not at risk if the rest of the complex or physical structure was not up to FHA standards, she said.
But that isn’t the only obstacle local industry experts raised.
Loan risks
One of the requirements that must be met for re-certification is that HOA dues must not be more than 30 days delinquent, and local Realtors, lenders and property management associations stated that is too short a period for an HOA board to be made aware of a problem and resolve it.
“There are some exceptions,” West said. “It can possibly go as high as 20 percent, but the biggest issue is not homeowners but lenders (who own individual units) that are not paying HOA fees while trying to market the property.”
The concern is the risk to the FHA-backed loans, she said. The condo complexes must have enough money in cash reserves to make repairs on the common areas.
For instance, if a roof needs to be repaired and there isn’t sufficient money to cover the repair of a roof, it affects all homeowners in the development, along with the value and FHA worthiness of their complex.
Realtors are having success in having lenders pay condo association fees, West said referring to the large lending institutions that have taken back properties in complexes but have not been paying association fees.
“Realtors are applying pressure on lenders. California Association of Realtors and National Association of Realtors both can be very effective and Realtors should be talking to their trade organizations for assistance.”
Given that, West said some misunderstandings in the market as a whole remain, and with trade organizations despite the FHA’s educational attempts via ongoing communications, webinars and its FAQs posted on its website at www.hud.gov/answers.
If a question is not answered, there’s a link where anyone can post a question and the folks in Washington, D.C. will answer and post it on the site, she said.
Requirements
Northern California resident Jeannette Way, who served as chairwoman of the General Housing Committee for the National Association of Realtors, said Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have no owner/occupancy ratio requirements and that bank-owned properties need to be eliminated from the owner occupied ratio requirements.
Not true, West said.
For one, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae do have owner-occupancy ratios, she said.
“And we have stressed over and over that REOs (bank-owned properties) do not count. Only condo owner and investor-owned condos are counted in the owner-occupied count.”
We also treat condos owned as a second-home as owner-occupied, West said. Many condos are vacation homes and while the owners do not live there year-round, we still count them as owner occupied, she said.
Steps have also been taken to assist the market.
Condo projects used to have to consist of a minimum of four units, West said. Now condo units need only be two units in project to qualify.
And under the Housing Economic Recovery Act, the owner-occupancy ratio was lowered from 51 to 50 percent, West said. While a one-percent change may not sound like much, West said it can make a difference if the complex is a large one.
The question looms for many, however, as to what is next to help the condo real estate market’s recovery which has seen dramatic price drops and lower sales volumes in the SCV when compared to the single-family home market.
Help for the market?
“That depends on how the economy proceeds and how quickly it gets better,” said Gene Gibson, public affairs officer with HUD for Region 9.
“The federal government takes its lead from Congress, Gibson said. “What we do to address this depends on whatever programs and bills they want to pass.”
Asked if any revisions are anticipated, Gibson said the president has been discussing a possible re-finance program but that neither HUD nor FHA will know until Congress makes or announces any changes.
Everyone will know when we know, Gibson said. We may know when something is in the works, but we have no idea of the outcome until its released to the public.
“Condos will always be the last to recover,” West added. “When single-family homes become affordable, people want to own a home.”
