Editor’s note : In 2010, the Santa Clarita City Council voted to form a city library system, resulting in a process and controversy that consumed much of that year’s news and carried well into this year’s, as well.
By Signal Staff
Sonny Chai, of Canyon Country, was at the Valencia Library on Wednesday with his daughter, Audrey Chai, 7.
“We’re here all the time,” Chai said. “They have everything you could possibly need.”
His voice would be music to the ears of Santa Clarita City Council members who have assured residents for more than a year that local libraries would improve under city leadership.
The Santa Clarita City Council voted 4-1 in August 2010 to withdraw from the county library system and form a city library system. Council members also voted to hire a private library-management firm to operate the new city library, reasoning they would save money that could be used to buy more books, keep libraries open longer and help pay off the city’s $28.5-million, 30,000-square-foot new Newhall Library.
The city saved enough money to do these things without an annual special library tax of $28 per property owner that the county had collected.
But a vociferous group of library users and their supporters opposed the move and the $19 million, five-year contract with Library Systems and Services LLC, or LSSI, arguing libraries are a public service that should be kept in the public domain with public workers.
Critics also questioned the city’s apparently quick decision to withdraw from the county and contract with LSSI, saying they didn’t feel the City Council listened to their concerns.
The battle lines were drawn.
Opponents of the move challenged its legality and ethics. They argued quality and privacy issues, championed access to collections immeasurably larger than any of the three held at the Valencia, Newhall and Canyon Country libraries, cited history and the value of access to a wide range of literature and other media.
They filed several actions in court, but the courts ruled with the city. A system whereby a city withdraws from the county library was already established.
The issue bubbled over the boundaries of the Santa Clarita Valley. Eventually, legislation was signed by Gov. Jerry Brown that would restrict such a city move in the future, calling it “privatization.”
The city responded that it wasn’t privatizing, but rather contracting out a service. It moved ahead with the plan, running into occasional snags on the way.
Shortly after the August 2010 vote, the county halted its improvements on the Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy library, saying it was no longer a county facility.
Negotiations began on the buildings and the existing collections.
Protests continued.
All the time, city officials insisted they could provide better libraries, be open more hours, with updated collections and improved technology — all at a lower price to residents than the county library system could.
After Canyon Country library was completed and reopened, it was discovered the floors were wet and the carpet ruined. The library had to be closed again.
But in July, the city proudly opened its three-library system. It has distributed almost 40,000 library cards, and the three libraries receive some 2,000 customers a day, city spokeswoman Heather Leuning said Wednesday.
“Library patrons now enjoy increased hours of operations, a $90,000 infusion of new books and media, upgraded facilities and new technology,” Leuning said.
“It’s been absolutely successful,” said Yuri Kenney, Santa Clarita Public Library adult services coordinator. “We’re very much able to respond to the needs and desires of the community on the spot.”
Kenney said repairs are still going on at the Canyon Country library.
“The carpet tiles were not adhering to the floor,” she said. “We had to remove all the shelves and all the carpeting to solve the problem,” she said.
The work being done at the Canyon Country library is covered under warranty and managed by the county of Los Angeles Internal Services Department, Leuning said.
The Canyon Country Jo Anne Darcy Library is located at 18601 Soledad Canyon Road. The Valencia Library is located at 23743 W. Valencia Blvd. The Newhall Library is currently located at 22704 W. Ninth St. The new, Old Town Newhall Library, which broke ground in March 2010, is expected to be completed in fall 2012.
