This is in response to Brian Baker’s letter published in the Jan. 8 edition of The Signal, “Oil pipeline comments way off base.”
While I have not decided on the merits of the Keystone XL pipeline, I feel there is one point that needs to be clarified:
Baker implies that the existence of this pipeline will lead to lower gas prices in the U.S. He uses electronics as an example of the free market leading to lower prices and better features. In this, he is correct.
But when he tries to imply that the oil industry is a free market, he shows either a lack of information on the basics of the oil industry or a basic ignorance of the meaning of a free market.
When you have a group who controls over 40 percent of the world’s production and their main goal is to set prices of crude by adjusting their production, you do not have a free market.
In addition, the closest refineries that can use the product from tar sands are in the U.S. Midwest. It would make sense to bring it to those refineries if all you want to do is produce for the U.S. market. That is not what the oil companies that mine the tar sands want. They want to ship the product to Texas because that gives them access to the ports on the Gulf of Mexico, so that they can ship worldwide.
In addition to the Keystone pipeline, the oil companies are looking to build a pipeline that can take the product to the west coast of Canada and then to Asia.
This pipeline is not going to automatically lower the cost of anything in America if the oil companies can sell it for more overseas.
There are also some major environmental concerns with the mining and processing of tar (oil) sands.
There are also groups of farmers, not normally considered leftists, in America who don’t want the pipeline crossing their properties.
If the reader is interested in looking at the pros and cons of this project, just Google “Keystone pipeline” and look at both sides of the issue — rather than listen to me or Baker — and make up your own mind.
