The Santa Clarita City Council election is nearly upon us. Expensive, color political mailings are appearing in voters’ mailboxes. Candidates must raise large sums from contributors in order to provide these mailings. Just reaching the high-propensity voters costs many thousands of dollars. Where is the money coming from for these fliers?
Unfortunately, our state Legislature did not pass the California Disclose Act, so we voters can’t easily get the answer to the question of where the funding comes from. AB 1148 would have let voters know who is really paying for political ads on the ads themselves. The legislation would have required the three largest funders of more than $10,000 be disclosed on political ads, including TV, radio, print, mass mailings and website ads.
In spite of a poll conducted in October by California Field Poll showing broad bipartisan voter support for this — 84 percent of voters favor the legislation including 78 percent of Republicans, 86 percent of Democrats and 88 percent of independents — our legislators recently voted against this bill. I guess they didn’t want people to know where their money would come from at election time, either. (You can find out which of our representatives denied the public this information by accessing the bill number at leginfo.ca.gov.).
One hopes that this situation will be remedied in future elections with the help of citizens working to qualify the Disclose Act as an initiative for the November ballot with a voter-signature petition drive.
Local residents have tried to verify candidate spending by reviewing the filings required by the Fair Political Practices Commission at City Hall. Unfortunately, there are ways around this. Mailing just after the filing date ensures that no one will have access to contributor information until right before or just after the election, when it is too late to do anything about it.
Another trick used is when candidates loan themselves money, then get repaid by contributions from their special-interest promoters after the election, when it is too late for voters to base their decisions on these contributions.
The easiest way is to do this is to form a political action committee to send out mailers. These PACs are not subject to campaign contribution limits and often just pay fines rather than reporting information when required since the fines are usually minimal.
Santa Clarita has had a long history of PACs financing local campaigns. One example is the PAC previously managed by Ed Colley (who is now running for City Council) called Citizens for Integrity.
In the last election, this PAC received $30,000 from G & L Reality Corp. The money supported current-Mayor Laurie Ender (another candidate in this April’s council election), who then supported and voted for the huge office towers scheduled to be built next to Henry Mayo hospital in a residential neighborhood zoned for low density. Ender has received a $1,000 donation from G & L Realty again in this election.
Candidates in other elections received substantial funding from developers, garbage companies and auto dealerships, all of whom have contracts, permits or advertising matters before the council.
Council candidates supporting the viewpoint of residents can not compete against such massive ad funding. Such funding discourages the political process by making sure that well-funded special interests have a louder voice in the political process.
The Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment has long supported proposals for campaign contribution and disclosure reform because where candidates get their contributions reflects who and what issues those candidates support. That is why it is so important to “follow the money.”
For example, in a previous statewide election, $235 million was spent just on ballot measures, in large part from corporations hiding behind misleading committees, such as “Stop Hidden Taxes” and “California Jobs Initiative,” two PACs financed by oil companies.
Proposition 26 passed after $18 million in ads, stopped the state or cities from raising fees, even on polluters, without a two-thirds vote. The three largest funders were Chevron, the American Beverage Association and Philip Morris. Tesoro and Valero Oil companies contributed about $30 million to PACs in an attempt to overturn California’s landmark global-warming law.
Democracy does not function properly without informed voters. Transparency and disclosure is important. And so is voting. In Santa Clarita, voting by mail has begun.
Of course, you can still vote at the polls April 10 — as I will be doing — or carry your ballot into City Hall on that day. I urge you to research the candidates and cast your vote for City Council.
I also urge you to sign the petition to get the California Disclose Act on the November ballot.
I will be casting one of my votes for TimBen Boydston because I think he will best represent the interests of residents.
Lynne Plambeck is president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment and a board member for the Newhall County Water District.
