On April 24, the Signal published an article “East Side: Man writes bond dissent.” Unfortunately, The Signal chose to omit several critical facts that I previously provided that demonstrate why this is such an expensive measure.
According to the financial analysis provided by the district’s assistant superintendent for business services, Measure CK would borrow $72 million in four series of bonds issued between 2016 and 2025. Unfortunately, the Series B thorough D bonds would borrow $38 million and have interest costs of $231 million — more than four times higher than the Series A bonds, which borrow a similar amount — $35 million but incur interest of only $54 million.
Total interest of $285 million is incurred along with the $72 million borrowed. Payments stretch for 47 years to 2064. The interest amount projected to be incurred by these bonds is nearly triple the $93 million that an amortizing 30-year loan would have using the same interest rates the district is showing.
Why are the series B-D bonds so expensive?
* There is not enough projected tax revenue to cover any payments for the first 14 years of their lives. This means that rather than a slowly declining principal amount, interest gets added to the borrowed amount (negative amortization), creating higher and higher interest amounts over time.
* The need to defer payments also increases the risk to investors and results in higher than normal financing costs (a projected 6.5 percent versus the 2.69 percent the Hart district just refinanced at).
* The payments are back-end loaded. For example, the payment in 2036 for the Series D bonds is only $1.2 million, while the last payment in 2064 is $18.8 million. Payments for the Series D bond would not fully cover interest for approximately 28 years from the time of borrowing.
* The bond terms are 39 and 40 years.
Schools can always find ways to spend additional revenue. But when taxpayers have to pay back five times the amount borrowed, voters and taxpayers should be asking hard questions about what is critically necessary for the schools versus what is just nice to have.
