Public education funding is at a crossroads, Santa Clarita Valley educators say.
One direction leads to the November ballot, on which two major California figures are battling over tax plans that, they say, would benefit education and reverse years of cuts.
The governor has established another path that overhauls just how much California school districts would be paid based on the students they serve. If adopted, it would mean a collective loss of $40 million of education funding in the Santa Clarita Valley.
And then there’s another option that puts school districts on the same path they’ve been on and leaves educators waiting on the state’s economy to turn around so that public education can be funded better.
Local educators and state leaders say it’s about time as years of multi-million cuts have disrupted the education of students and threatened the education of thousands of children locally and across California.
“We need some relief from the state,” Saugus Union School District Superintendent Joan Lucid said. “We can’t continue to do what we’re doing in relationship to our students without some sort of state assistance.”
Time to tax?
One of the more pivotal changes to education funding could come later this year if two major tax initiatives make their way onto the November ballot.
“I do think that either one of those initiatives can finally stabilize education funding,” Newhall School District Superintendent Marc Winger said.
Gov. Jerry Brown and civil rights attorney Molly Munger have two separate tax initiatives they are hoping to land on the November ballot.
Both proposals are still in the signature gathering stage, although educators across California speculate that both initiatives will come before California voters in November.
Brown and Munger both say that the ballot measures would benefit education through new taxes, but the methods are different.
Brown wants to stabilize the state budget while Munger wants to create a special fund to help reverse state cuts to education.
And both tax measures have faced severe criticism from tax opponents, especially Brown, with independent and watchdog groups saying that he is overestimating how much the new taxes would generate.
Brown’s measure includes a quarter-cent sales tax increase and a series of income tax hikes for California residents making more than $250,000, according to the proposal.
Munger’s is a slide scale income tax that would generate $10-$11 billion in new revenue. For instance, a couple earning $75,000 in income would pay $428 a year while a couple making $1.5 million would pay $27,266, according to the proposal. Among the biggest differences in her tax proposal, which has garnered the support of the California State Parent-Teacher Association, the money raised through the taxes would be placed in a separate trust fund that stops the governor and California Legislature from spending it.
School districts would receive the boost in funding according to a formula.
For the first four years, the money would be split between special education funding, student spending and preschool and early childhood programs, according to the Our Children, Our Future proposal.
For instance, the William S. Hart Union High School District would see an estimated $24 million during the 2013-14 school year, according to the proposal.
By 2023-24, that figure would soar to just over $57 million for the Hart district.
Reform may backfire
The governor has a completely separate proposal that is in the early legislative stages and would be detrimental to Santa Clarita Valley school districts, local educators say. Unlike the voter-initiated tax measures, Brown’s proposal is taking shape through the legislative process with a series of committee hearings and reports.
The governor introduced the concept, known as a weighted formula, in January as part of his 2012-13 California budget plan.
The current proposal, which is expected to be heavily debated in the coming months, would transform how school districts are funded and lead to a collective $40 million loss in money each year from the five local school districts.
Among the biggest hits would be for the Hart district, which as the largest local school district, would lose nearly $30 million in funding, according to a study drafted by local educators and given to state politicians and educators in Sacramento.
Each of the school districts would receive a flat rate of $4,920 per student.
On top of that, school districts would be able to earn more money for students who are considered English language learners or come from low-income homes.
While that formula benefits low income districts, like Los Angeles Unified School District, it won’t do much for local school districts.
“That works really well in districts where you have a high number of (English-language learners) or students on free and reduced price meals,” Lucid said. “Neither which we have.”
That proves to be a challenge for local educators.
“It’s a double edged sword,” Lucid said. “You want kids to be successful and mainstream, but in the same token, you lose those dollars.”
Local school districts would rather see a higher base rate, something closer to $6,000, as a way to give them a better edge in serving students.
“The weighted formula does not bode well for this valley and does create losers of every single district,” Lucid said.
Challenges in recovery
After years of state budget cuts to education, local leaders say there may be sign of a rebound, but it will take time for local school districts to feel the effects of growth, especially as they face unique obstacles.
“We need to realize that this recovery is occurring, but this is going to be a slow pace,” Sulphur Springs School District Superintendent Robert Nolet said.
By the end of next year, the state will owe Sulphur Springs about $24 million in cuts and deferrals, Nolet said.
A major issue for local school district has been deferrals, in which the state delays paying districts money they are supposed to get.
School districts receive a majority of their funding from the state, with little support from the federal government and local revenues.
Currently, school districts receive about 79 cents for every dollar from the state.
But Santa Clarita Valley school districts face another challenge because they receive less money than other school districts in the state as part of an outdated funding formula that dates back to the 1970s. The formula faces an uphill battle in being revamped because it’ll require other California school districts to give up its funding to benefit local school districts.
Saugus Union, Newhall and Sulphur Springs school districts are among the bottom 10 elementary school districts in Los Angeles County for funding per student. For instance, Saugus Union received $5,016 per student in 2010-11 with Newhall a few dollars above with $5,034, state figures show. In contrast, the average amount is $5,329 for county school districts.
Although stability may be in sight, without prompt action, local educators say the 2013-14 fiscal year will be a significant challenge for school districts.
“At some point in time, people, businesses and school districts just run out of financial resources,” Newhall School District board member Suzan Solomon said. “My personal opinion is that the state of California has no specific priorities in terms of its budget. Everything is a priority, but nothing is a priority.”
661-2875518
