ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Gas price wars: San Diego has fought them

Divorce may be a peculiar term to apply to the petroleum industry, but "divorcement" is exactly what several municipalities in San Diego County have tried to do to the oil companies and the service stations they operate.

Early last year the San Diego County Board of Supervisors and 16 of 17 cities passed "Divorcement and Fair Wholesale Pricing" ordinances which would prevent oil companies from directly selling gasoline to consumers — essentially allowing only dealer stations — and would eliminate pricing zones, otherwise known as redlining.

Oil companies set wholesale prices differently in different zones based on what the market will bear. Last week it was learned that dealers in Santa Clarita were paying 3 to 10 cents more than other Southland dealers for the same brands of gas — one of the reasons gas prices in the SCV are among the nation's highest, according to a recent Automobile Club of Southern California survey.

Divorcement is the law in Nevada, Maryland, Virginia, Washington D.C., Connecticut, Delaware and Puerto Rico. In San Diego County, traditionally one of California's priciest areas for gasoline, there was a catch to passing the legislation: It had to be passed by cities representing two-thirds of the county's population. The city of San Diego comprises approximately 60 percent of the county's population, so that city would have to be part of the equation.

"Encinitas said OK, but only if the city of San Diego went along with it," said Lauren Wasserman, city manager of Encinitas which, like many cities, repealed the ordinance in the fall of 1998 when the city of San Diego backed down.

According to the Automotive Trade Organizations of California (AuTO-CA), an advocacy group representing over 2,500 gasoline retailers and others in the auto service industry, county supervisors passed the ordinance with the assurance that the city of San Diego would also approve it and share in litigation costs. The city of San Diego passed the ordinance 9-0 on the first reading, but that's where it stopped.

The Western States Petroleum Association, representing the oil industry, immediately filed suit against the county and the city. The city never brought it back for final passage, so the county tabled it.

Rick Grenell, press secretary for San Diego Mayor Susan Golding, said Tuesday that his boss was opposed to government interference with market forces.

"The mayor didn't want the government to be involved in price supports or price controls," said Grenell.

Instead Golding supported efforts to prod the industry into lowering gasoline prices itself. About six months ago, Grenell said, the city officially began drawing attention to low-cost gas stations by publicizing them on local cable television stations and listing them on the city's website, which currently shows the names and addresses for gasoline retailers with prices ranging from $1.059 to $1.099.

"There was a lot of news coverage," Grenell said. "Even the TV stations got involved in highlighting (gas stations) that have low prices. ... (It) forced (gas) stations to adjust their prices lower. Our gas prices are lower now than L.A.'s. Before they were not."

Duane Bernard, a San Diego gasoline dealer and AuTO-CA board member, said that isn't the real reason pump prices have come down.

"Gasoline prices have slowly come down because of the (Federal Trade Commission)," said Bernard, explaining that the FTC forced Shell and Texaco to spin off 30 area gas stations when the two oil giants merged. Those 30 stations, now flying the Exxon flag, are run by one very competitive jobber who operates on a tiny margin, forcing others to compete, Bernard said.

Dealers in Santa Clarita say there is little they can do on their own to cut pump prices.

"Most dealers work on a 3 to 5 percent margin. It's pretty small," Randy Cressall, owner of Valencia Chevron Auto Spa, said last week. "(People) don't realize that the oil company truly sets the (pump) prices" when it sets wholesale prices for dealers.

Also, according to Freeway Shell's George Mayer, one dealer might be charged one wholesale price while a company-owned station or a station down the street, just blocks from the Interstate 5 corridor, might be charged a lower wholesale price — something divorcement and fair wholesale pricing would address.

The San Diego dealer noted that the oil companies paid $300 million to settle a lawsuit alleging they had engaged in illegal retail price fixing to create the Iranian oil crisis in the mid-1970s. Now, ironically, the oil companies share wholesale and retail prices legally.

"Lundberg conducts daily surveys. They call me every day and ask my wholesale and retail prices. They compile that information and sell it to the oil companies," Bernard said.

Bernard refuted the oil industry's contention that high state taxes are responsible for high gas prices in California.

"When I was in Newport, R.I., I paid 99 cents for gasoline when it was $1.20 in San Diego and L.A.," he said. "And Rhode Island's taxes are higher."

Bernard pointed to legislation introduced by State Sen. Steve Peace which would enable gasoline dealers to circumvent the oil industry's price zoning by letting them purchase their company's product from more than one wholesale source.

Known as "branded open supply" legislation, SB 123 "(provides) that a refiner, distributor, manufacturer, or transporter of petroleum products may not prevent a branded gasoline franchisee from purchasing the franchisor's branded petroleum products from any location or through any vendor in the franchisor's wholesale network."

In other words, Bernard said, "If a Chevron dealer, for instance, in your area is paying 20 cents more than a dealer in Torrance, he could pay the same price and get it from the same place as the dealer in Torrance and haul it by truck (to his station). It would let him compete and the price would come down."

Peace, D-El Cajon, reintroduced the bill Dec. 21 after similar legislation, sponsored by AuTO-CA and consumer groups and opposed by the oil companies and the California Chamber of Commerce, failed along mostly party lines in June 1997.

Sen. William J. "Pete" Knight, R-Palmdale, who joined Republicans in voting against the bill, did so out of concern for independent petroleum haulers.

"One of the sticking points was that a bunch of independent haulers could lose their jobs," said Cameron Smyth, Knight's deputy chief of staff.

Given the new information about gas price discrepancies, however, Knight "is going to be much more receptive to legislation that lowers costs and brings equality (to prices)," Smyth said.

"When we see that Santa Clarita has the single highest gas price in the state, that's information we hadn't had before," he said. "(Knight) will give every consideration to supporting anything that will bring balance to the cost of gas across the state."

← Back to 1999

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/0199/012899a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,122 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_business
  • text:valley_names [4 distinct/6 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Chamber of Commerce]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By LEON WORDEN]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”, “Knight, R-”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0