"What's wrong with this picture?" asked Seth Fearey, pointing to a photograph of the nondescript entrance to the Valencia Industrial Center. "What's the identity of this region?"
Nothing tells visitors they are entering the most important industrial park in Los Angeles County, Fearey said — no mock-up of the SR-71 to tell people this is where Lockheed designed the plane; no giant movie reels to tell people that a whole lot of filming goes on here; nothing to say what makes the place special.
Fearey, a Palo Alto economist hired last year by The Newhall Land & Farming Co. to analyze industries throughout the Santa Clarita Valley, addressed members of the Valencia Industrial Association at a luncheon last week.
"People don't know who you are or what you've got here," Fearey told the group. "It makes it hard to recruit people. You've got no reputation, except that you're too far" from downtown Los Angeles.
But wait a minute. Why should one type of industry get more attention than another? And besides. In a world where buyers and sellers come together with a few clicks of a mouse, does location really matter anymore?
It does, says Michael Porter, a professor at the Harvard Business School.
"If location matters less," Porter postulates in a recent edition of the Harvard Business Review, "why, then, is it true that the odds of finding a world-class mutual fund company in Boston are much higher than in most any other place?"
Or a shoe company in Italy? Or a high-performance auto maker in southern Germany? Or a casino in Las Vegas? Or a winery in Napa Valley?
A cluster is
an industry-focused , geographical concentration of interconnected companies and institutions that have achieved unusual competitive success.
"Today's economic map of the world is dominated by what I call clusters — geographic concentrations of interconnected companies and institutions ... that have achieved unusual competitive success in particular fields," Porter writes.
Fearey charted a model cluster as a pyramid, with exporting industries at the top level. Exporting industries are those that sell goods or services outside the immediate geographic region — in this case, the Santa Clarita Valley. Every other employer in the region depends on these industries because they bring wealth into the area from outside.
In the middle of the pyramid are the businesses that support the exporting firms: suppliers of parts, machinery, services.
At the base are the institutions that provide an economic infrastructure for the rest of the cluster: governmental agencies, chambers of commerce, trade associations, vocational training centers.
All three levels must be strong for a cluster to be healthy, Fearey said. A healthy cluster increases productivity, fosters innovation and spurs the formation of new businesses — bringing wealth into the area and creating economic independence.
Cluster strength, Fearey said, is "becoming increasingly important in the new economy as giant (companies) break up and go to out-sourcing " for goods and services — from graphic design work to the manufacturing of parts.
Porter writes: "A cluster allows each member to benefit as if it had greater scale or as if it had joined with others formally — without requiring it to sacrifice its flexibility."
Challenges
Santa Clarita has "one leg on the stool" when it comes to aerospace, and a film cluster is emerging — but there are challenges, said Fearey, who has spent much time in recent months studying employment figures and meeting with local business leaders.
Wages in the SCV are relatively low, and as a result there is a "massive exchange going on every day." White collar executives who live here travel to Los Angeles, while blue collar workers in the San Fernando and Antelope Valleys come to Santa Clarita in the morning to work — clogging freeways and creating a brain drain.
Santa Clarita's industrial weakness, Fearey said, is in suppliers — the middle layer of the pyramid.
"You are very thin on specialized services. There aren't enough lawyers here," Fearey said only half jokingly, noting that the number of corporate attorneys in an area is an indication of the value of the intellectual properties they protect. "We have a lot of lawyers in Silicon Valley."
Clusters:
Increase the productivity of local companies
Drive the direction and pace of innovation
Stimulate the formation of new businesses
"You've got to collaborate (and) work together to attract suppliers" and not "leave it up to Newhall Land to figure out," Fearey advised.
On the plus side, Santa Clarita has some assets to foster cluster growth, Fearey said: a high quality of life, strong community spirit (residents often volunteer their homes for movie shoots, he noted), and first-rate training programs through College of the Canyons.
"COC is really exceptional," Fearey said, citing the COC-operated Center for Applied Competitive Technologies at Aerospace Dynamics International in Valencia. The center teaches computer-aided drafting and manufacturing techniques in a hands-on environment and was recently named the best public-private partnership program in the California Community College system.
Analysis
"Aerospace is the dominant cluster" in the Santa Clarita Valley, Fearey said. "You've got a gorilla there."
Using Standard Industry Code data from 1991 to 1996, Fearey analyzed Santa Clarita's aerospace, film & entertainment, printing, and information technology sectors and found the area to be dominated by small companies with an average work force of 14.
Santa Clarita has an above-average concentration of aerospace firms and machine shops with an above-average number of employees per company, Fearey said. Their customers are aircraft makers and space vehicle manufacturers, and some are catering to the automotive industry in the wake of the past decade's military downsizing.
The obstacles are that aerospace firms are "scattered across the whole Santa Clarita Valley," and "again, the middle layer is thin. A lot of parts are shipped to Los Angeles for special treatments. There is an opportunity to strengthen service providers."
Filming and entertainment, with 70 percent growth over the five-year period, is another cluster worth cultivating, Fearey said.
"Most of the industry is the four-wall studio and movie ranches," he said. Some of the important infrastructural elements are in place, such as the SCV Film & Entertainment Bureau, local hotels, COC and California Institute of the Arts.
But most local studios and ranches employ only four or five people, and that's a problem, Fearey said. Of the $394 million generated locally by the movie industry in 1996, $352 million went to payroll, not to vendors. The money wasn't pumped back into the local entertainment economy.
The picture could change if more support services were based in the Santa Clarita Valley. The Motion Picture General Store, providing a variety of rental equipment and expendables for the movie industry, opened recently at Legacy Partners' Filming Facility in Valencia; without more services like that, film makers purchase their supplies in Burbank and Hollywood, "hardly (leaving) a penny in the local economy," Fearey said.
"When they film here, there is a truckload of people coming up Interstate 5" to do make-up , provide props and so forth, Fearey said.
Although there is hope for building up the local film industry, printing "turned out not to be a good industry to look at," Fearey said. Printing was "the only (cluster) during the boom time that actually declined," shrinking by 8.5 percent of its work force as book printers chased cheaper land and labor in the southeastern U.S.
Large printing companies in Valencia that have remained successful, such as Harte-Hanks and Bertelsmann Industry Services, have done so only by becoming more "technology oriented" and broadening the variety of services they offer.
The technology sector itself is "real hard to define," Fearey said, because there were too few high-tech firms in the SIC codes to analyze. They employ just six workers on average and are "scattered all over the place."
But they pay almost double the average SCV wage of $25,267 (Employment Development Department, 1996), and they doubled in number over the five-year period.
Construction, while larger than other industries in terms of local employment, was presumed not to be an exporting industry and was excluded from further analysis.
Opportunity
Piquing Fearey's interest was the discovery of firms involved with themed entertainment.
"There are about 10 firms that make things that go into casinos and amusement parks," he said — Technifex and Attraction Services, for example.
"It's a very exciting industry, and it brings together (facets of) aerospace (manufacturing) and entertainment," Fearey said.
It also feeds the growing "experience economy," where the product being sold is an experience. "Its inventor was Walt Disney," Fearey said.
In another edition of Harvard Business Review, economists B. Joseph Pine and James Gilmore liken the development of the experience economy to the evolution of a child's birthday party, and the birthday cake that mom used to make.
An experience
occurs when a company intentionally uses services as the stage, and goods as the props, to engage individual customers in a way that creates a memorable event.
"Now, in the time-starved 1990s, parents neither make the birthday cake nor even throw the party. Instead, they spend $100 or more to 'outsource' the entire event to Chuck E. Cheese's, the Discovery Zone, the Mining Company, or some other business that stages a memorable event for the kids — and often throws in the cake for free. Welcome to the emerging experience economy."
"An experience is not an amorphous construct," the authors write. "It is as real an offering as any service, good, or commodity. ... An experience occurs when a company intentionally uses services as the stage, and goods as the props, to engage individual customers in a way that creates a memorable event."
"This transition from selling services to selling experiences will be no easier for established companies to undertake and weather than the last great economic shift, from the industrial to the service economy."
When you go to the Hard Rock Cafe or Planet Hollywood, say Pine and Gilmore, you know you're in for a particular experience. In contrast, retailers who talk about "the shopping experience" fail when they don't actually create a theme "that ties the disparate merchandising presentations together into a staged experience."
Six Flags California creates an experience for visitors — and keeps it fresh whenever a new ride opens at Magic Mountain.
But Six Flags is "pretty well self-contained ," said Fearey. Other than the local hotels and restaurants that rely on Six Flags patrons for a portion of their income, there aren't necessarily opportunities to develop a business infrastructure around the local theme parks because most equipment comes from outside the country and is serviced on-site by Six Flags' own personnel (many of whom use a portion of their income to pay for their education at COC, Fearey noted).
Rather, said Fearey, the real opportunity is for Santa Clarita to grab hold of the types of companies that develop the robotic controls and pyrotechnics and other special effects that are used in amusement parks and casinos and trade shows around the world.
"There is a lot of potential to build themed entertainment," Fearey said. "There are about 300 (such companies) in the L.A. basin. There are a lot in Burbank and Hollywood. A lot are growing and need space."
"There is no concentration in the world that compares to what (there is) in Southern California, and nobody has really claimed ownership of themed entertainment," he said.
"It's going to be a lot of hard work and (there must be) a compelling vision" — and that will be the subject of further talks with local business leaders, Fearey said.
