When consumers provide researchers with a list of the 25 most important factors that go into the decision on where to spend money, price came in 16th.
But this surprising fact and many others like it are mysteries to small businesses who are struggling to stay alive when huge retail stores with national reputations open in the same market area, a leading consultant told a group of Santa Clarita Valley business people Tuesday.
Kent Burnes is in the SCV for a series of three discussions. The second, "Help! I've Lost My Customers and Can't Get Them Back," will be delivered today at Santa Clarita City Hall from 6 to 9 p.m. His visit to the SCV is sponsored by the city and the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce, with help from PacBell Directories.
A nationally known consultant in the battle to market small businesses, the Grass Valley-based Burnes is making his third visit to the SCV. He will also visit close to two dozen businesses for offer first-hand advice on what can be done to increase profitability.
Tuesday's seminar, "How to Compete With the National Discounters," took a look at the changing marketplace. In the SCV it has been radically altered in the last five years with the addition of retailers like Wal-Mart on The Old Road and more specialized "big box" stores that include Home Depot and Best Buy.
"We Americans are coming out of a period where we just bought cheap stuff," Burnes said. "Consumers are not as fixated on price as (small business owners) are."
But many independent merchants believe that the ability of national chains to purchase merchandise in huge quantities and pass along bulk-buying discounts to shoppers is the biggest weapon in the big boxes' arsenal. It isn't the truth, Burnes said.
A recent poll of SCV business owners suggested that most are looking for help in providing better customer service. Burnes said the survey that placed price well down the ladder in customer importance also indicated that various aspects of customer service were near the top.
But many small businesses lack the tools and strategies to improve in this area.
Burnes' family has been in retail for several generations, he said.
"My family and I compete with the big boxes the minute they hit the ground, because they're not quite settled in yet," he said. "And most of them turn over 60 to 70 percent of their employees every year."
But he said he welcomes doing battle with the behemoths, which have grown so prevalent they tend to clutter entire areas and cannibalize each other. He said the biggest threat might be the even-smaller small business, the one-man operation that is often Internet-based.
These businesses have negligible overhead and use technological savvy to thrive.
Meanwhile, he added, 50 percent of the mom-and-pop businesses do not use computers, and 40 percent don't have fax machines.
What's worse, an estimated 70 percent of busy Americans do the bulk of their shopping after 4 p.m. When small businesses close for the day at 5, it automatically sends customers to the 100,000-square-foot retailers near the freeway.
"Wal-Mart grosses between $350 million and $400 million a day, and their inventory stays in their system for a maximum of 14 days," Burnes said. "But you walk into a small business and you see merchandise that's been there 180 days. Some of it's been around 'since my dad had the store.'
"Technology can manage how much we buy and how we're selling it."
Appearance matters as well. Most big stores feature end caps, the large, attractive displays at the end of aisles. Consumers assume those items are on sale and pick up items from these displays; frequently the prices are not reduced.
"We need to reset ourselves," Burnes said. "Stand in front of your business ask yourself if you'd come in here. If we're going to be $2 more expensive than the big box store, we had better look $10 more expensive."
But many don't know their own business, and don't look at it as a shopper would. Large chains spend millions a year on "mystery shoppers," people who anonymously visit stores and report back to the home office on any deficiencies. Burnes said he solved one client's problems by calling the business and playing the tape of the customer service clerks back to the shocked CEO.
"Try calling yourself, or get someone to be a customer," he said. "You might be surprised."
