Only one of the top 15 brokerage houses had a recommended stock portfolio that outperformed Standard & Poor's 500 stock index over the last 12 months, and that has the firm's local stockbrokers buzzing.
"We are very excited about this," said Marilyn Drummond, investment representative in the Lyons Ave. office of Edward Jones.
"We were the only firm that beat the S&P index, with a one-year increase of 12.3 percent compared to 9 percent for Standard & Poor's," she said. "What's so significant is that number two had only a 3.6 percent increase and only three were in positive (territory)."
The list of 15 firms, compiled by Zacks Investment Research of Chicago, showed that the stocks recommended by most major brokerage houses declined in value over the 12 months ending Sept. 30. Only Edward Jones, Prudential and A.G. Edwards saw gains.
For the quarter ending Sept. 30, all recommended stock portfolios lost value and none beat the S&P 500, which dropped 9.9 percent during the period. Edward Jones tied Bear Stearns for the best performance, down 10.5 percent on the quarter. Worst performer for the quarter and the year was the "buy" portfolio of Florida-based Raymond James, which fell 31 percent and 27 percent in the respective periods.
The S&P 500 index saw a 147.9 percent increase over the last 5 years, according to the report. PaineWebber's "buy" list outperformed the pack for the 5 years with a 172 percent increase, followed by A.G. Edwards at 178.8 percent and Edward Jones at 142.2.
Edward Jones' position at the top of the list for the most recent quarter and year shows that the company's investment philosophy works, Drummond said.
"Our number-one ranking is a true testament to our buy-and-hold philosophy," she said. "We recommend a diversified portfolio and we don't believe in turnover. ... The market has experienced significant volatility over the past several months, and the investors who have weathered the storm with the blue chips have fared well."
Drummond said Edward Jones' portfolio had the lowest turnover among the 15 firms, with zero changes during third-quarter 1998 and only one so far in the fourth quarter. With 53 picks, the firm's portfolio was also the largest.
"Rather than trying to pick record-setting stocks, we look for quality companies that offer attractive growth that will do well over the long term," she said. "At Edward Jones, we remind our investors again and again that it's time in the market, not timing the market, that is critical to investment success."
Drummond said California is a fairly new market for the St. Louis-based firm, which offers a full spectrum of services at over 4,500 single-broker offices in the U.S., Canada and U.K. including two in the Santa Clarita Valley.
