Sales tax is the single biggest source of revenue for the City of Santa Clarita. The more sales tax revenue the city can generate, the more it can spend on services for local residents.
The prospect of a Nordstrom department store looming on the horizon is the latest manifestation of a desire to capture more retail sales tax dollars. Capturing sales tax dollars has been on the minds of community leaders for a long time — even before the city of Santa Clarita was formed in 1987.
"We felt that a lot more money would stay in this valley if we incorporated (as a city), and I think that has been proven," said Carl Boyer, the original chairman of the City of Santa Clarita Formation Committee, who went on to become a city councilman throughout the city's first decade.
Boyer said city formation leaders estimated that in the 1980s, Santa Clarita Valley residents were responsible for generating $3 million to $4 million more in tax revenue than they were getting back from the County of Los Angeles in the form of services. Creating a city would keep local tax dollars local.
Today, the city of Santa Clarita gets to keep and spend one percent of the value of every taxable retail sale made within city limits. If a shopper spends $100 at the Valencia Town Center and pays $8.25 in sales tax, the city gets $1, which it can use toward filling a pothole or paying a deputy sheriff's salary.
If a shopper spends $100 at the Valencia Marketplace in Stevenson Ranch and pays $8.25 in sales tax, however, the city of Santa Clarita gets nothing. Stevenson Ranch is located in unincorporated county territory. The $1 in local revenue goes to the County of Los Angeles, which might spend the money in the Santa Clarita Valley, but might spend it somewhere else.
The issue of benefit to Santa Clarita becomes more complex when other factors are taken into consideration. If a Valencia Marketplace employee spends a portion of his paycheck inside city limits, the city benefits, as it does if a store in the Valencia Marketplace contracts with a Santa Clarita-based supplier of goods or services.
Nonetheless, the benefit to the city is greatest if it can directly capture sales tax dollars. To that end, the city provided incentives to encourage Home Depot, Price Club-Costco and the Valencia Town Center to develop stores inside city limits. In the latter case, the city offset some of the cost of roadwork around the Town Center with federal grant money that was also used for roadwork near the Soledad Entertainment Center and on Railroad Avenue in Newhall.
There is no dispute among local government and civic leaders that the city of Santa Clarita is still "losing" sales tax revenue because Santa Clarita residents still make some of their retail purchases outside city limits.
But how much revenue is coming into the city from people who live outside city limits? How much is coming into the Santa Clarita Valley from other areas of Southern California? And do those amounts offset the amount the city is "losing" to stores in Stevenson Ranch and the San Fernando Valley?
In other words, does the city, or the Santa Clarita Valley, have net retail sales tax "leakage" ... or a surplus?
Dollars in, dollars out
"I think it's a stretch to think there is really a lot of draw from outside the valley," said Mike Haviland, economic development director for the city of Santa Clarita. "It's a perception issue. People (in Los Angeles) still think we're in a desert."
Charlie Gill, executive vice president of Urban Retail Properties Co., which manages the Valencia Town Center and other malls throughout the nation, disagrees.
"Our studies indicate that we have drawn substantial numbers from Granada Hills, Sylmar, Northridge, the northern San Fernando Valley fringe, Bakersfield, Palmdale, Lancaster and Acton over the last two years," Gill said.
Why would someone who lives near the Northridge Fashion Center shop here?
"There is a perception of customer safety here," Gill said. "Our customers tell us they come here for the comfort and safety."
"All our advertising is clued to a concentric circle map (to show people) that the mileage to the Valencia Town Center is less than traveling laterally" to other shopping centers, Gill said. "I think our customer counts show inroads into those markets because the atmosphere (at the Valencia Town Center) is more acceptable."
Haviland agreed that the Valencia Town Center drew substantial numbers of shoppers from the San Fernando Valley after the 1994 earthquake, when the Northridge Fashion Center was closed, but said the phenomenon was temporary.
"In regard to the in-migration of money, the only time it was significant was after the earthquake because (the) Northridge (mall) was down," he said.
Haviland said he was unaware of any study that compared money flowing out of the valley to money flowing in, other than an obscure portion of a study that was completed for the city in April 1995.
Performed in the context of downtown Newhall revitalization, the study examined retail sales in Newhall and compared them to growth in retail sales over time in the city of Santa Clarita and the County of Los Angeles.
Based on data provided by the State of California Board of Equalization, the study found that in 1989, shortly after city formation, retail sales tax revenues per capita within city limits stood at 88 percent of the countywide average. By 1993, however, retail sales tax revenues in Santa Clarita had climbed to 104 percent of the countywide average.
Stated differently, according to the study, "In 1989 sales were 'leaking' out of the local area, probably to places in the San Fernando Valley such as Burbank, Glendale and Sherman Oaks. By 1993, with a substantially larger population than in 1988, Santa Clarita had managed to stop the leakage and recapture all of those purchases, or equivalent purchases, that had formerly been made elsewhere.
"In fact, sales exceeding 100 percent of the countywide average indicate that Santa Clarita was attracting more purchases from outside the city than it was losing to retail outlets beyond the city limits. The opening of Valencia Town Center in 1992 no doubt helped achieve this change; other major stores, such as the Price Club-Costco and Home Depot also contributed to Santa Clarita's drawing power."
By itself, the study nullifies the perception that more money is flowing out of the valley than is being returned from outside residents. However, the study is almost four years old, and much has changed. It examined sales figures that were posted before the earthquake, which brought retail sales dollars into the city, but also before the opening of the Valencia Marketplace, which draws an unknown number of retail sales dollars out of the city.
The current survey
In July the city published a survey that gauged the retail shopping patterns of Santa Clarita Valley residents. What it does is provide an understanding of where SCV residents spend their money. What it does not do is identify how many retail sales tax dollars the city is capturing from people who live outside the valley.
"We've been rather defensive" in terms of the studies the city typically conducts, Haviland said. "We've focused on how much (we are) losing out."
PTM Research and Gregory Stoffel and Associates sampled 400 Santa Clarita Valley residents in a random telephone survey in June 1998. According to the report, "The study asked where respondents shopped both in and outside of the (Santa Clarita) Valley, how respondents rated various characteristics of key retail centers in the valley, and what reasons respondents gave for their retail shopping preferences."
Valencia provided 25 percent of responses to the 18 survey questions, Newhall 23 percent, Saugus 23 percent, Canyon Country 16 percent, and under 6 percent each from Castaic, Stevenson Ranch, Agua Dulce and Val Verde. The survey had a 5 percent margin of error.
92 percent of the respondents said they shop in local retail stores, inside or outside city limits; 69 percent shop outside the Santa Clarita Valley, and 56 percent shop from catalogs.
94 percent said they shopped at the Valencia Town Center in the last six months, 40 percent at the Northridge Fashion Center, 27 percent at the Glendale Galleria and 20 percent at Topanga Plaza.
Among local shopping centers, 65 percent of respondents said they shopped most often at Valencia Town Center, 11 percent on Soledad Canyon Road, 8 percent each at the Bouquet Canyon Plaza, the Valencia Marketplace and on Lyons Avenue.
62 percent said they preferred to shop at regional or national stores instead of locally owned and operated stores.
The consultants analyzed the data.
"The (Santa Clarita) Valley does not offer everything this population shops for. This is demonstrated by the fact that 69 percent of them have left the valley to shop during the past year. Significantly, those leaving have lived in the valley longer than those who stay in the valley to shop."
"They also have the valley's higher education levels and household incomes. We speculate that, over time, shoppers increasingly need to leave the valley to find what they want."
What do they want?
SCV shoppers purchase 70 to 75 percent of their clothing, gifts, movies and appliances in the Santa Clarita Valley, and when they dine out, they eat here 72 percent of the time. Local residents purchase 59 to 70 percent of their shoes, housewares, home electronics and sporting goods here, while local stores capture only 56 percent or less of the local market for furniture, carpeting and flooring, and cars and trucks.
Among those who leave the Santa Clarita Valley to shop, 21 percent shop at Macy's, 17.5 percent at Nordstrom, 16.5 percent at JC Penney, 12.5 percent at Robinson's-May, 12.5 percent at Sears, and 5.3 to 7.5 percent at Price Club-Costco, Target, Kmart, Wal-Mart and Mervyn's — even though JC Penney, Robinson's-May, Sears, Price Club-Costco, Target, Kmart, Wal-Mart and Mervyn's operate stores in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Why?
"More variety-better selection" and "better prices" were the top reasons mentioned for shopping outside the valley.
In tandem with the evidence cited by Valencia Town Center manager Gill, "you feel safe when shopping" was the number-one reason mentioned for patronizing shops in the Santa Clarita Valley, followed by "atmosphere is pleasant," "merchants are friendly" and "parking is easy."
The report concluded that "Without a reason, (Santa Clarita) Valley residents are not going to change their shopping habits. So if the retailing community wants to alter the present paradigm, it must take the lead."
How?
The survey outlines three strategies.
1. Provide for the areas that are lacking — furniture, carpeting, flooring, cars, trucks and high-quality department stores.
2. "Put a Macy's and a Nordstrom in the valley and most of these people will not leave."
3. Adapt the "Main Street" concept being developed at the Valencia Town Center to Newhall.
"Bringing in a new retailer is a (long) term and ... difficult endeavor, we know," the consultants said. "But this research proved that the valley is worth a hard look, and perhaps a formal study, by Macy's and Nordstrom's planners. Larger or more upscale furniture and flooring retailers might also be attracted by the results presented here.
"The Santa Clarita Valley has much to offer retailers willing to tailor their offerings to the needs and desires of (the SCV's) retail shoppers. And in this research (the SCV) now has direction from adjusting and expanding retail infrastructure to increase payroll and sales and tax revenues."
The upshot
The city's current survey, coupled with other statistical and anecdotal evidence, suggests that people who live in the Santa Clarita Valley shop outside the area because of perceived lower prices and greater selection, while people who live outside the valley shop in the city because of a perception of greater safety and comfort.
In any case, people who live in the Santa Clarita Valley spend some of their retail dollars outside the city and the valley, and some people who live outside the valley spend some of their retail dollars here.
Which is more? The question lingers.
