HOLLYWOOD — Santa Clarita sent a six-member contingent Wednesday to the Hollywood Entertainment Museum, where a larger than expected crowd of independent studio owners, actor and director union representatives and service providers told a state Assembly panel that incentives offered by Canada and other governments were placing California's film industry at a competitive disadvantage.
Calling the state's entertainment industry "the engine that has driven economic recovery in California," committee chairwoman Sheila Kuehl, Speaker Pro Tem of the Assembly, assured industry leaders that there is a growing concern in the lower house about production moving away from California.
"We are concerned about production moving to Canada even though there may have been good reasons for the move," Kuehl said. "We are trying to quantify the problem."
Kuehl said the intent of the day-long hearing was to solicit information from the industry on the dollar value of California's loss, to examine the incentives other states and nations offer and to "see what we can do" to help the industry.
Executives from broad sectors of the industry responded by saying something must be done to counterbalance the cash giveaways that the national and provincial governments in Canada and other nations use to attract producers.
"Foreign competition threatens to erode both the quality and quantity of the filming industry here," said Bryan Unger, assistant executive director of the Director's Guild of America, in testimony before the Assembly Select Committee on Entertainment and the Arts.
The problem, Unger said, is that producers — especially producers of low-margin products, such as movies of the week — are fleeing to Canada in droves because the Canadian government rebates 11 percent of the labor costs when production companies employ Canadian crew members. Certain provinces, such as Ontario and British Columbia, rebate an additional 11 percent when indigenous workers are used, he said.
Ron Silveira, speaking for the post-production industry, told the committee that the problem is not limited to front-line personnel, such as actors and directors.
"We embrace new competition because it makes us more efficient and stronger," Silveira said. "However, we need you to ... help us level the playing field."
Silveira said California's post-production industry started to feel the loss of business to Canada three years ago. In the past it was hard to find skilled artisans in Canada who could perform competent editing, mixing and duplicating work, but today there are high-caliber facilities in Vancouver, Montreal and Toronto, he said.
Jeff Morton, manager of the Polsa Rosa movie ranch in Acton, said he has been "cautiously optimistic" about free trade agreements such as NAFTA and GATT but questions the fairness of Canada's actions.
"I cannot understand how Canada can claim to be a free trade partner when they are paying producers cash money to leave the United States," Morton said in written testimony to the committee. "Paying producers' crew labor expenses and ... reimbursing the producer for the vendors' labor expenses is not a practice that I can compete against. Nearly all production will eventually leave simply because I can't give labor away."
Morton said his movie ranch was hit hard by a series of events — first the El Niño storms, then a threatened actor's strike, and now the "Canadian problem."
"Any country that uses its tax base to directly pay businesses to leave the U.S. is acting onerously and in violation of the good will intended by any free trade agreements our country engaged in," he said.
"We're wondering if we'll still be viable in 1999," he said.
According to SCV Film Bureau liaison April Aston, the entertainment industry was not addressed in recent federal trade agreements.
Morton feared that other countries would follow Canada's example. Several of Wednesday's speakers indicated the problem had already started to spread.
"We have been approached to build facilities in other states and nations," said Michael Moore, president of the independent Raleigh Studios, which operates two facilities in the Los Angeles area. "I will tell you, they are literally rolling out the carpet ... in terms of trying to package incentives."
Scott Ross, representing visual effects artists, said visual effects production is 40 percent cheaper in Australia than in the U.S. because of a government subsidy.
Screen Actors Guild president Richard Masur said SAG was studying the specific dollar losses attributed to runaway production and did not yet have hard numbers for the committee. However, he estimated that during the 1995-96 season, approximately 2,600 acting jobs had been lost because companies that otherwise would have filmed in California set up shop in Canada and hired Canadian talent. For the 1998-99 season, those estimated job losses have climbed to 11,300, he said.
"For every acting job, several crafts jobs are lost as well," Masur added. "That should be a concern to all of us."
Dr. Ed Kawahara, an economist with the California Trade and Commerce Agency, told committee members that filming is a $27.5 billion industry in California and that every 1 percent of entertainment jobs lost in California translates into a $9 million loss in state sales tax revenue.
"Overall, the industry is basically ours to lose," Kawahara said.
SAG's Masur said Canada has exploited what was once "sort of a proprietary technology" of Hollywood.
"When I was filming in Canada (several years ago), they could crew up two films in Toronto and two in Ontario and that's it," Masur said. "Now there are 30 to 40 projects in both cities at any given time. We created a crew base in Canada by training (talent) with our dollars."
While Masur said he did not have any specific recommendations for the Assembly panel, others, such as Ed Clare of the Production Equipment Rental Association, suggested that the Legislature should provide tax credits and relief from sales tax for the rental or purchase of movie equipment.
For Morton of Polsa Rosa, real relief will require the efforts of both the state and federal governments. But the unanimity he heard from industry leaders Wednesday was an encouraging signal.
"For everyone to be at the table together and (saying the same thing) is extraordinary," Morton said. "This wouldn't have happened 30 or 40 years ago."
