Californians are feeling great confidence in the economy, and rightly so. Job growth is soaring, unemployment is at record lows and people are satisfied. Much of the renewed economic prosperity in California can be attributed to state and federal legislation over the last decade that has transformed California into a friendly place in which to live, work and do business. We must continue down that well-established path.
The California Chamber of Commerce is working to keep California lawmakers moving down that road toward economic growth. We recognize that balancing all the components contributing to a strong economy and keeping them moving forward are not easy tasks.
One example of a successful balancing act was the decision by the California Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC) nearly two years ago to move California to a 40-hour workweek. This change allowed employers and employees to work together to develop flexible schedules that balanced the individual needs of the worker and the needs of the employer. Both employers and employees were better off with the change.
Unfortunately, a legislative proposal has been introduced in Sacramento that will undo the good work done by the IWC and will stymie California's employers and employees.
The proposal is AB 60 (Wally Knox, D-Beverly Hills), which would rescind the 40-hour workweek that took effect January 1998, and return California to the eight-hour workday. Overtime pay would be based on an eight-hour day, rather than the current 40-hour week. AB 60 would make California the only state to reject the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, which is followed by all other 47 states in the continental U.S.
AB 60's inflexible, "one size fits all" approach will leave employers and employees hamstrung, without the ability to craft individual flexible schedules that are so important to today's workers. AB 60 also establishes unnecessary, confusing paperwork, procedural and accounting requirements for employers who attempt to try to provide their workers with some flexibility in their schedules.
* * *
Two years ago, employers and employees together convinced IWC to adopt the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, instituting the 40-hour workweek. Interestingly, the impetus for change was the 1994 Northridge earthquake.
To speed up rebuilding earthquake-damaged freeways in Los Angeles, Gov. Pete Wilson signed an executive order allowing the 40-hour workweek. Once repairs had been made, the governor rescinded his executive order. After receiving letters from both employers and employees favoring the flexibility allowed under the 40-hour workweek, Gov. Wilson directed the IWC to review the policy and in April 1997, it voted to institute the 40-hour workweek beginning January 1998.
Since the change, the 40-hour workweek has been a resounding success for both employers and employees. Employees have the flexibility to take a few hours off one day to attend a child's school function, a doctor's appointment or whatever, and make it up later in the week without losing pay or using vacation time or sick time. Employers are satisfied because the work is being done and their employees are happy.
AB 60 jeopardizes that flexibility. In many cases, employers will be hard pressed to offer flexibility because it will mean paying overtime, and employers simply can't afford to pay overtime for make-up time. Any smart businessperson tries to ensure that work is done during normal business hours and overtime is reserved for unforeseen circumstances.
* * *
The problems that AB 60 poses for employees are extensive:
AB 60 mandates "one size fits all" restrictions. AB 60 limits alternative workweek schedules to a maximum of 10 hours per day before overtime takes effect. Even before California moved to the 40-hour workweek, 12-hour workdays — if approved by employer and employee — were allowed. College students or those who work only a few days a week prefer to work longer hours so they can make more money. Under AB 60, they will lose income.
AB 60 limits the number of make-up hours — time paid at regular time — to four in one week. Four hours of make-up time is simply inadequate. In most instances, employers will be reluctant to pay overtime for any make-up time beyond four hours.
AB 60 offers false flexibility. Although supporters of the bill point out that AB 60 allows employers to offer employees a menu of alternative schedules, employers and employees still lose the ability to negotiate one-on-one to determine individual schedules that work best.
AB 60 creates a paperwork, procedural and accounting morass for employers who try to provide alternative work schedules. Because of the numerous hoops employers will be forced to jump through, AB 60 will actually discourage employers from offering flexible schedules.
For example, AB 60 requires a secret ballot to be approved by two-thirds of affected employees to begin an alternate work schedule; requires employers to report results of the secret elections to the Department of Labor Statistics and Research within 30 days of the vote; limits the number of times employees may vote on alternative work schedules to once a year; requires triple time be paid for the same hour of work; and requires new civil penalties be placed on supervisors and payroll clerks who make mistakes in calculating payroll.
* * *
AB 60 is most vocally supported by organized labor, which has been trying to portray the AB 60 debate as employer vs. employee. As the chair of an association whose 11,000-plus members are employers providing jobs for more than 2.5 million Californians from all industries, sizes and locations, I know this to be a gross mischaracterization. Non-represented employees, who make up 80 percent of California's workforce, and all employers are fighting to keep the 40-hour workweek.
Interestingly, unions are not subject to the provisions in AB 60 because they negotiate their own wage contracts (which usually include flexible work schedules). One could make a legitimate case that organized labor supports AB 60 because it mainly keeps flexible scheduling as a benefit for union members only, making AB 60 one way to increase the ranks of union members.
AB 60 still must wind its way through the Legislature before becoming law. It passed out of the Assembly Labor and Employment Committee on a party line vote and will be heard next on April 14 in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
As the leading business organization in California, the California Chamber of Commerce has a responsibility to its members to keep California's business climate healthy. Californians are well known for their innovative, "outside the box" approach to everything they do. We must keep it that way and reject proposals like AB 60 that restrict our state's progress.
AB 60 will not help California's economy, its workers or its employers. It only hampers efforts to institute innovative, flexible schedules in the most forward-thinking state in the nation.
Gary M. Cusumano, president of The Newhall Land & Farming Co., is chairman of the California Chamber of Commerce. "Inside Business" appears Sundays and rotates among SCV business leaders.
