Several months ago, I wrote a column titled, “What Does Business Owe Society?” Today I would like to address a topic that is near and dear to my heart: government.
When I graduated from college a quarter-century ago, I believed that government could do no wrong, and that it could make a difference in the lives of people. However, my views on the role of government have changed dramatically over the years.
Businesses are like most people: While they want to pay their fair share of taxes, they also look at the return received for the tax dollars that were paid. I call this Return on Taxation, or ROT. As an example, what incentive does a business owner have to try to increase the size of his business, when he will be taxed more heavily for the effort he has made to create more jobs for people?
It is difficult to understand how taxes are “progressive” when the more someone makes, the more he is forced to pay. To that end, I have identified some areas in which government agencies need to satisfy their business constituencies.
Safety
First and foremost, a business will not begin operations (or stay in a location) where it is not safe. In order for a person to invest in building his company, there must be a reasonable feeling that the facility is protected and will be left untouched when no one is there at night and on weekends.
As an example of the importance of safety, consider the business owners in South-Central Los Angeles who used to be in business prior to the 1992 riots.
Not too long ago, I looked at some office space in an older part of town, and I was advised to expect that the office would be broken into. That warning dissuaded me from conducting my business in that location, as I would not feel safe investing in a lease, furniture, and other equipment necessary for business operations.
If a municipal government cannot or will not provide a safe environment for a business to be located, fewer jobs will be created and retained. Additionally, the lack of safety will serve as a deterrent to private investment in the area.
Education
Education is the backbone of our society. It is the single largest competitive advantage that our nation possesses. Compared to the rest of the world, our educational system does well because the majority of people worldwide do not have a formal education.
The world is no longer operating in the industrial age; we are moving very rapidly to the information age. In order to be a part of these changes, a person must be educated. Government funds public education through taxes and students today can receive an education (from elementary school through college) for next to nothing. Considering the price an individual must pay to receive it, education is a bargain.
Even though we lack major competition, most of you reading this column would probably agree that we haven’t experienced the return that we should. Government is doing a poor job educating its people, and one major hurdle is the lack of alternatives for disciplining children who cannot or will not behave while in school. Public education is mandatory, but the schools have no recourse to force any child to behave, get along with others, pay attention, complete assignments, show respect for property, and not be disruptive.
Another problem is the lack of involvement by many parents who send their children off to school and expect the school to teach manners, appropriate behavior, time management and academics. Teachers are expected to be social workers, surrogate parents, disciplinarians and educators.
Yet we expect these same students to evolve into employees who behave, get along with coworkers, pay attention, do what they are told, act respectfully, and have the skills needed to help the business.
If people do not learn these fundamental societal skills when they are young, what hope does our civilization have for when they get older? Without these basic skills in the work force, the employer will end up paying twice to get them the skill set they need— first through taxes for public education, and then through the payment that is made to get the employee reeducated and up to speed.
Is it any wonder why the largest corporations tend to be located in areas where the public school systems are the strongest? Not many years ago, Amgen had a choice of where to locate in Southern California. Instead of choosing Los Angeles, the primary city in the region, the company chose Thousand Oaks. Is it any wonder why cities like Simi Valley and Santa Clarita attract good businesses that pay good wages?
Yet, if you ask any teacher, there are still problems in these public schools with children who don’t behave in class, don’t complete their homework, and who have parents who want to be “friends” instead of “parents” to their children.
As a business owner and consultant, I know there are not any easy answers to these problems. In fact, some of you might disagree as to whether there are any problems at all.
If that is the case, I suggest that you do two things. First, visualize moving all of your valuable belongings to the worst part of town. You probably wouldn’t do it because you wouldn’t feel they’d be safe there, yet business owners are criticized when they won’t keep their business in a location that is not considered safe.
Second, take one morning to sit in a class at a school where your children don’t attend. Don’t sit in the kindergarten class, but visit the upper grades instead. Watch how the students behave and then picture those same students working in your business, speaking with customers on whom you depend to make payroll.
When you’ve done that, you’ll be like me, wondering if my ROT is where it needs to be.
Kenneth W. Keller is president and CEO of STAR Business Consulting Inc., a Valencia-based consulting company focused on the needs of mid-sized , growing businesses. Keller can be reached at (661) 295-6837 or [email protected] .
