A recent article appeared in The Wall Street Journal under the title “The Cheater Principle.” This was a real eye-opener for me. It described in great detail how individuals, all of them with the ability to pay, and possessing the full knowledge that they are doing wrong, are cheating like never before.
The article highlighted people running tollbooths, sneaking into movie theaters, leaving restaurants without paying the tab, returning merchandise that was soiled and dirty to stores— stores where it hadn’t been purchased.
I had initially intended to write about how leaders need to set the standards for their organizations to be effective and efficient. I may address that topic later. Today I’d like to discuss ethics in business— how business leaders, managers and owners can set the standard for those they work for and with.
For many years, the American public has held business people in low regard. Poll after poll indicates business leaders rank somewhere in the neighborhood of politicians.
Given the “good time” economy that the entire nation is enjoying, opinions have been put on the back burner and are rarely discussed. Because the profits that are being generated are now shared through various stock purchase plans, 401(k) and other employer-sponsored savings plans, everyone focuses on the bottom line. The greater the profits, the greater our individual share.
However, this comes at a high price. The Firestone tire recall stemmed from the fact that people were more focused on profits and production than safety. The United Airlines apology to customers for poor service came as a result of that company focusing on volume and market share, and not about those from whom they receive income— their customers.
It used to be that the scariest words in the English language were “Mike Wallace of 60 Minutes is here to see you.” Now, to criminal, crook and hero alike, it is a badge of honor to appear on a television show where we “bare all” and we do so without regret. We have become a society of the celebrity. As a society we no longer believe in doing the right thing. Our “honor,” if you can call it that, comes from being noticed, from being caught even though we tried to “get away with it.”
In both the Firestone and United examples, apologies were made, but in both cases, they were the result of decisions management made. While I give the leaders of both companies credit for addressing the issues, I hold them responsible for having knowledge that the course of action they took would have severe consequences.
During the Tylenol tampering scare years ago, the leader of that company explained his case for dealing with forces outside of his control that threatened to destroy the reputation of his company. That leader received high marks for quickly going on television and asking that the public maintain its confidence in Tylenol. The company immediately found a way to solve the problem through tamper-proof packaging, now a norm in many consumer products.
Doing the right thing each and every day is an issue that needs to be addressed, not just for those of us in business, but for our customers and clients, and for those who look to us as examples— our children. The tone of our business begins and ends with the person in charge. As business owners, we have to make a stand. Doing this may not win any popularity contests, but it will benefit all of us in the long run.
There are four general rules to follow when you are trying to determine if something you are doing, or thinking about doing, is the right thing.
The first is whether you would enjoy seeing your action exposed on the front page of the local newspaper. How you would face your family, neighbors and business colleagues if your activities were laid out for the world to read in The Signal? The Wall Street Journal?
The second is whether a jury of your business peers would review your activities favorably. Would people in your industry or in business in general approve of your actions? Or would they feel disdain for you, thinking you an idiot?
The third test is whether you would like to tell your story to your mother or your minister. The love and affection they give you is unconditional, but they may also be disappointed in you.
The fourth test is whether your actions are legal, within the spirit and letter of the law. While some may argue that this is not a valid test, the truth is that our system of laws and justice, despite flaws, is the best on the planet.
I can’t tell you what to value. I cannot tell you what is right. I will tell you what I value, and perhaps you can give some thought to how you can go about doing the right thing in your organization.
I believe, and very strongly so, in education. I give a lot of credit to people who take on the challenge of improving themselves. Education is one of the ways people can better themselves, and in this country we have essentially free education all the way through college.
I make a point of hiring college students from this area to work in my business. I encourage them to continue their studies and offer advice when asked.
I value the basics of business etiquette. I define that as showing up on time, being in the frame of mind to actually do a day’s work. I value people doing work when they are paid to do so. I value taking care of the customer. I strive to provide my customers with more than just service. I try to provide my customers with satisfaction.
My brother Jim used to tell me, “Do more than is expected” — and I do that for my customers. I value hard work and commitment. I expect those around me to do the same thing.
When I was growing up, my parents used to ask me if I were willing to jump off the Golden Gate Bridge just because “everyone else was doing it.” Once I figured out how high the bridge was, how far the drop was, how cold the water was and what it would feel like to hit something akin to concrete going damn fast, I was able to make up my own mind.
I have, with all the courage that I have, charted a course of action for my life to do the right thing. How about you? What course of action to do the right thing are you taking?
Kenneth W. Keller is principal of Keller & Associates, a Valencia-based marketing consulting business that focuses on the needs of emerging and growing businesses. Keller can be reached at 254-3642 or at [email protected] . His commentary appears Sundays.
