ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

We have met the enemy and we are it

All year long, I have been on a crusade to improve customer service at the places I visit, the places I spend time, the places I spend money.

I have heard from many people who feel the same way I do. The overall opinion is that service is bad and is not getting any better. Our friendliness and compassion following the events of Sept. 11 have already started to fade from memory.

This past week I read an interesting article on McDonald’s restaurants. The company is not doing as well as it has in the past. While the results of the business could be blamed on either an overabundance of competitors or the vast array of consumer choices now available in the “quick serve” industry, the problems this company faces are internal, not external.

And that is true of most businesses.

I am not singling out McDonald’s or any of its competitors. Anyone reading this should understand that every business is, essentially, its own worst enemy.

Even McDonald’s understands this, as a senior executive was quoted as saying: “If we stay focused on the needs of the customers, the sales will take care of themselves.”

The problem occurs, of course, when organizations don’t stay focused on the needs of customers. Instead, they focus on something else... whatever that might be.

Someone I met with told me about managing by magazine article. Or, maybe the fad of the day.

The Wall Street Journal hired a company that specializes in “mystery shopping” to visit 25 McDonald’s outlets in New York, Chicago, Dallas and the Los Angeles area from Nov. 7 to Nov. 15, to measure how well the employees did versus expectations. I want to share with you the results, but go one step further: to make the transition to your business and how you can apply the lessons learned.

At the counter

Overall, McDonald’s achieved a 72.4 percent out of 100 percent for service at the counter. Sixty-four percent of the employees greeted customers with a smile, despite McDonald’s slogan, “We like to see you smile.”

Thirty-six percent of the employees suggested a food promotion or suggested a larger size. Fifty-two percent summarized the order for accuracy.

In your business, how often do you or your employees greet a visitor— either on the phone or in person— with a smile? I know one manager who has a mirror on the desk of every person in the department so they can make sure they are smiling while talking on the telephone. How many receptionists have a mirror they can look into so they can see how they look when speaking with a customer?

I am amazed that approximately only half the customer orders were called back to insure accuracy. How many of the orders your customers place are checked for accuracy? If you could measure the cost of inventory, shipping and receiving for a single order that was not double-checked , every business would put into place a process to improve this vulnerable area.

It is not just the cost of what I call the misfunction... there is also a cost involved with unhappy customers. They might not just come back.

At the drive-thru

Amazingly, only 50 percent of the employees thanked the customer for their purchase. Seventy percent handed out the proper utensils, which included napkins. Twenty percent suggested a larger-size item.

How many times do you or your employees thank your customers for their business, the order, or the relationship? Probably not often enough. How about just sending a note to your customers thanking them for past business just because you want them to know how much you care? I have one supplier who takes the time to write “thank you” on every check we send.

I learned as a child that the words “thank you” were the two most important words in the entire English language. Somewhere, somehow, that simple message is no longer being taught or executed. Instead, we hear “Have a nice day!” or “See you soon!”

What we all need to hear more often— in fact, 100 percent of the time— at the end of a business transaction, is “thank you.” It shows respect and appreciation.

What type of processes do you have in place to make sure every customer gets your version of napkins with their order? Wouldn’t you appreciate being asked if there were anything else you wanted or needed? Many “ up-selling ” profits are lost because simple things aren’t done.

Versus the competition

Overall, McDonald’s rated 81.9 percent in the survey. At the same time the shoppers were also visiting Burger King (ranked at 80.1 percent), Wendy’s (80.7 percent) and Taco Bell (77.1 percent). The firm conducting the surveys indicated that the average for all restaurants (both quick-serve and sit-down ) is 80.0 percent.

I interpret this to mean that the restaurant business is willing to settle for 80 percent and McDonald’s is only 2 percent better than average. Look at it another way: this is a B- grade and is acceptable, but just so. There is a lot of room for improvement.

So, why would I continue to go to a place and spend my money where the service is only average? Why would a customer do business with you if your business were just average? Especially if there are alternative choices that are higher rated?

Improvements needed

My suspicion is that the people that own and manage these restaurants are not spending the time to hire the right people, training them, setting standards of performance and then taking corrective action if the expectations are not met.

Ownership and management must be vigilant at all hours, every day of the week. I shouldn’t have to settle for unacceptable service just because it is Sunday afternoon or Tuesday night and the “big boss” isn’t there. The people at work should provide me with a smile, and a “thank you” regardless.

Operational excellence could help an organization stand out versus the competition. That has to be a goal of the company. That goal is set by ownership and it must be executed by the management every day.

How does your company measure up? I suggest that you take a lesson from McDonald’s and realize that you can’t be just average in terms of how you execute and believe that your business will just get better, because it won’t unless you make the decision to make the business better. Start with your people— they hold the key to your customers.

Kenneth W. Keller is the principal of Keller & Associates and is a director of Renaissance Executive Forums, a program for mid-sized growing business owners. He can be reached at 661-295-6837 or at [email protected] .

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/guest/1201/122301b.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,121 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_business
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0