ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

'Titanic Syndrome' at fault for XYZ thinking in film biz

An old-time baseball pitcher, a pretty good one by most standards, never seemed able to win more than 14 games a year. He won 13 or 14 about five times and never won 20 games, the litmus test for excellence in pitching.

When he was asked why he couldn't win 20, the pitcher shrugged and said, "Aw, if I did it once they'd expect me to do it every year."

Maybe that's the problem with some of the people in the motion picture industry. We're in the height of the summer release season which has become, for Hollywood, almost like the retail industry's version of Christmas. It's the season the money tree blooms.

Well, it's not blooming for "Godzilla" like it was supposed to, and there are some people at Sony Pictures who are very, very disappointed.

I think Sony and maybe the industry at large is falling victim to something we might call the Titanic Syndrome. If "Godzilla" is the hyped-up summer film that costs a lot of money to make -- the estimates, including promotional costs, are $200 million -- the industry expects, and maybe demands, it make as much as "Titanic." Like the baseball player who couldn't win more than 14 games, you become a victim of everyone's unrealistically heightened expectations.

At the latest count, when Exhibitor Relations Co. came out with its box office statistics at the beginning of last week, "Godzilla" had earned more than $123 million in four weeks. That's in American and Canadian theaters; between foreign release, including Japan, and video sales it is expected the film will eventually be a modest money maker for Sony.

"Titanic" has earned almost $600 million domestically for Paramount Pictures and, six months after it opened, the number is still growing. It can, in fact, still be seen on a large screen in the Santa Clarita Valley, at the compact-priced Plaza Cinemas on Lyons Avenue. It's become the all-time money-maker because of repeat visits -- probably because of the love story and because Leonardo DiCaprio is a hot property in the sex-symbol market, a lot hotter than Matthew Broderick. "Godzilla" premiered on four screens at the Edwards Cinema at the Valencia Town Center when it opened over Memorial Day weekend. It was on more screens nationwide, about 3,300, than any film in history. It is now playing on one screen in Santa Clarita, and its weekly box office take dropped 36 percent last week.

I don't get the choice to play film critic very often. Allow me a chance to criticize other film critics for a moment. The creative team behind Godzilla, director Roland Emmerich and writer Dean Devlin, came up with "Independence Day" a couple of summers ago, combining the familiar earth-vs.-the-flying-saucers plot with the subplot soirées we used to see in the disaster movies in the 1970s. Every character in "Independence Day" came with baggage. They were either in love, wanted to find love, had lost love, had lost faith, had lost ambition, had lost their marbles or, in the case of one character, had been abducted by aliens who did "sexual experiments" on him. And, oh yes, in the midst of this backwash of backstory, there were these huge, malevolent flying saucers.

Apparently Emmerich and Devlin decided there would be none of this in Godzilla. The huge monster never once asked Emmerich "What's my motivation?" There was no explanation for its showing up in New York City; the film just cut right to the chase and attacked. There was little backstory, little character development, little memorable dialogue, and all of this was OK with me. "Godzilla" was a typical summer popcorn popper and a lot of fun. I'd rather have a flat story with a lot of fun scenes than put up with characters mouthing pithy platitudes for two hours like in "Independence Day."

But critics were harsh with "Godzilla" and its perceived shortcomings, which I'm sure haven't helped at the box office.

A news source in the Santa Clarita Valley working in the film industry may have hit the nail directly on the head when he talked to me about Sony Pictures and its lack of entertainment industry bookkeeping smarts. In short, he said, Sony doesn't really get it and may never get it. Here's a company that rose from the ashes of World War II and became probably the leading electronics manufacturer in the world. Americans who did not have a Ford or a Chrysler in their driveways had a Trinitron in the family room and another in the kitchen. Sony had a huge share of the home entertainment market, and then they decided to become a Hollywood player.

But Sony seems to think that X plus Y, using sound business bookkeeping, has to equal Z. It doesn't work that way in motion pictures, when creative processes must be accounted for and when sometimes your carefully scheduled film shoot has to be scrapped because the script calls for a sunny day in the park when it's cloudy. I'm sure Sony thought that if they spent Titanic-style dollars on "Godzilla" it would yield that kind of profit. There are too many variables, like film critics who ignored the dorky dialogue in "Titanic" and "Independence Day," then skewered "Godzilla" for its absence of meaningful script, to take anything to the bank. And, there's just too much competition during the summer to assume anyone would go to the same movie four times.

Sony's lesson is something local businesses in the SCV have to learn, too. At a film vendor seminar held a few months ago, business owners listened to a panel of industry pros tell them that, if they want to make money selling product or services to the film business, basically they have to throw their regular ideas of how things work out the window. Movie-making doesn't run on a 9-to-5 clock. If the sun comes out and the director suddenly decides to film that scene in the park, you may be asked on an hour's notice to rush a prop, or a costume, or 50 meals, over to the set.

If you tell the location manager, gee, we're closed Saturday, he'll cross you off the list and a real good opportunity will be lost. All because you thought in logical terms of X, Y and Z, like the producers of Godzilla, and not the way you're supposed to think in the film industry.

* * *

Jack Katzanek is the Signal's business editor. His column appears Sundays. He can be reached at 805-259-1234, extension 237.

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/katzanek/062198.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,092 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [business editor]
  • text:valley_names [5 distinct/7 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Lyons Avenue, Town Center]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0