ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

General Motors paid dearly for contentious labor relations

The old credo has it that you can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar. Unfortunately, General Motors received enough vinegar to season all the lettuce in Salinas.

And it drowned General Motors. It isn't easy to read the scoreboard at the end of a labor dispute, but my take is that if a strike lasts more than a month, the boss is the loser. In GM's case it was a $2.2 billion loser, and this is for a product that had taken a few black eyes in the minds of many consumers before the United Auto Workers took a walk.

It was a strike that didn't have to happen but did, because part of General Motors' strategic plan was to have as contentious a relationship with the union hierarchy as possible. It's not the strategy at Ford or Chrysler, where the CEOs have a normal relationship with the head of the UAW's division for those companies. The top man at Ford, I've read, regularly gets together for dinner and plays golf with the union's chief negotiator for Ford employees. They don't necessarily have to be buddies and invite each other to their children's weddings, but it makes good business sense to get to know your adversaries on a first name basis and develop some mutual respect to grease the wheel when it comes time to talk contract.

Not so at GM, where the top dog probably said to his secretary, "Get me whatzizface from the union on the phone. You know, the jerk with the cufflinks." It was a relationship that GM intentionally kept as adversarial as possible and was probably a $2.2 billion mistake. Union workers, on the other hand, can get unemployment help when they're on strike and benefits from the union strike fund, plus lots of coffee and doughnuts and camaraderie while they walk the picket lines. So I'll leave it to you to decide who lost and who won.

It takes two to create a two-month labor dispute tango, so I won't try to decide who was right. By working on a quota system, General Motors employees were working far less than an eight-hour day. As an employee who works at least that many hours every day and usually longer and drops by on days off to take care a few things, I find that difficult to respect. I don't find GM's request that its workers put out as much effort as other companies' outlandish. And I'd speculate that if the old "haste makes waste" slogan still works, it would mean that rushing through the day to hit a quota so the workers can go home early to watch "Days Of Our Lives" could lead to a less-than-superior product, which makes only the people at Toyota and Honda happy.

The GM strike, of course, had little effect on Santa Claritans. We're a long way from Flint, Mich. The dealerships on Creekside Road never ran out of cars, although there was the incorrect perception on the part of some that the supply had dried up.

The strike last August by the Teamsters against UPS did hit a lot of people in the SCV because United Parcel Service was the delivery agent of choice for 80 percent of America, including local merchants who depended on them for fresh supplies of practically everything and to ship out finished goods. Tuesday marks a year since that strike started, and I wasn't particularly encouraged by the fighting words I heard on the phone from union and management spokesmen the other day.

It sounds like this issue is headed for arbitration, because it involves how the contract that settled the strike will be interpreted. Since an arbitrator is also a lawyer, we'll just have to let him do his job.

But, to land on both sides of the issue once again, UPS claims it can't add 2,000 new jobs from its part-time ranks because they are delivering a half-million fewer packages a day. During the strike some businesses looked up Federal Express' and Roadway Packaging Service's telephone numbers and forgot UPS'. The UPS official I spoke with said "We can't hire 2,000 people to deliver packages that don't exist," and it's tough to argue with that logic.

On the other hand, the UPS guy didn't say profits were down. Just volume.

There are some that insist labor asks a lot in these negotiations and they may have a point. Certainly GM workers should not be immune from having to work a full day. UPS employees and others in certain situations have to live with the possibility that there will be times the boss can not afford a raise.

But the bottom line should be that if management is fair, treats employees as if they were people to be valued, pays them fairly for hours worked, then there wouldn't be expensive strikes and maybe there wouldn't even be unions any more.

The biggest line item on a business budget is usually salaries. I suppose it's irresistible for them to look to trim in that area, or to get more out of that line item. Too many times it's means trying to squeeze blood out of a rock, in the form of increasing the work load without having to pay for it. One of the most popular ways to do this, labor advocates say, is to try and finagle a way around overtime laws. A few weeks ago I learned Mervyn's is accused of pulling just this kind of an end run, by allegedly "promoting" employees to higher positions without giving them management responsibilities or salaries. Kind of like making the guy who sweeps the sales floor the Executive Senior Vice President in charge of brooms. This newly promoted management person is still dancing with the same broom, only as a "supervisor" he's no longer entitled to overtime.

This has just been classified as a class action suit, meaning a whole bunch of Mervyn's employees can get their names on the dotted line. The answer to this will probably be decided in court unless management decides not to fight it, but the question probably wouldn't have come up if management had played fair from the outset.

Just like GM wouldn't have lost $2.2 billion and two month's production if the CEO had treated his union counterpart as a respected fellow businessman and not as some sleazy enemy.

* * *

Jack Katzanek is the Signal's business editor. His column appears Sundays. He can be reached at 805-259-1234, extension 237.

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/katzanek/080298.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,089 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [business editor]
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: SCV]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 4, national 0